Konoplyanka vs Depay

[rooneyaldo]

Who is the man? Who would be the better signing if we are indeed in the market for a new winger. They both seem talented and available for a decent price. So people who have watched either in action, what would you say their strengths and weaknesses are?

 

[Bojan11]

Depay is younger and if managed right could be world class.

Konoplayanka would be an improvement on our wingers.

 

[Devil may care]

Depay has talent but looks a little like he has Nani-brain. Kopo is a dull touchline hugger. I'd go with Depay as he's younger and has more potential.

 

[Rykker_4united]

Ideally I'd have neither but if forced to pick one probably Memphis Depay.

 

[|Neo|x]

Depay does look like he has more potential but he does play in a league where defending is quite questionable, not that Ukraine league is anything special, but it is a lot more physical. Given the choice of the two I'd still take Depay, he does look like he could become a very good player, could go either way with him really, but at the moment there is not much between the two and Depay is 4 years younger.

 

[Walters_19_MuFc]

I haven't seen much of Depay, but i'd definitely have Konoplyanka as a squad player to replace the likes of Young or Nani.

 

[Ibi Dreams]

Depay seems the more exciting transfer to me, Konoplyanka is probably about as good as he'll ever be whereas Depay still has time to become something great