Killer instinct lacking?

ryansgirl

Full Member
Joined
Nov 4, 2001
Messages
2,935
Location
where the sun rises
As those who read my posts will realise, I don`t follow the `let`s shake up the team` line. I am prepared to be patient and see what happens further down the track before agreeing with those who think some established players should be sold, etc.

However, somebody made a valid point about Laurent Blanc helping a Manchester City player in the derby. I think it was the poster by the name of Remi Moses. The photo did not look good - I think Laurent looked a bit of a joke virtually massaging the legs/foot of a City player.

Somebody pointed out that Choccy McClair had helped David B (from Coventry when he had that appalling, freak injury at Old Trafford) but I think that was a completely different situation. THAT was a shocking accident whereas seeing Blanc doing that in the derby made me feel slightly embarrassed for my team. The City player either had or was feigning cramp or some slight injury and either way Laurent was silly to get involved.

The question I really am posing is - are some (not all) Manchester United players lacking a killer instinct and that is contributing to the lacklustre (by MU`s high standards) performances?]
I remember the Manchester United of a few seasons back (Treble and before) that was so ruthless and effective - our team had the killer instinct without being dirty or employing underhand tactics.In the past, a defender would never have behaved so passively towards the opposition. If an opponent had a simple case of cramp or whatever, that was their problem.

Maybe that photo demonstrates to some extent a lack of that killer instinct and ruthless will to win that was absent last season and is absent this season. Anyone care to comment?
 
What`s more, if Keano had been playing during the derby he probably would have had a go at Laurent for that silly action.
<img src="graemlins/devil.gif" border="0" alt="[Devil]" /> <img src="graemlins/devil.gif" border="0" alt="[Devil]" /> <img src="graemlins/keano.gif" border="0" alt="[Keano]" /> <img src="graemlins/keano.gif" border="0" alt="[Keano]" />
 
i disagree.

i don't think 'killer instinct and ruthlessness' have anything to do with being compassionate.

Larry is a professional - a true one at it. He may not be a Red completely, but it surely doesn't mean he doesn't want to win.

i saw it as an action in which to get the shitty player up and running ASAP. if Larry had left him there the guy may not have gotten up for a few more minutes, even worse for us IMO.

i can't argue with you that some of our players may not love this club as much as most others, but i have to say i don't agree that the compassion we show towards oppositions have anything to do with not wanting to win.

it's called fair play. FIFA and all other football assiociations emphasize on this very much - they even give away awards for it. it shouldn't interfere with how much your will to win. You can be a winner while playing professionally and treating other players professionally as well.

Gary Lineker was a winner at heart, yet he was such a gentleman about it. England as a national team has always been a fair team - and have never once failed to come out and say how much winning means to them.
 
moreso, weren't you the one who came out to say you could not tolerate the act of diving in the penalty area by Ruud? it's almost the same thing here.. it's about your professionalism.

a guy can dive two thousand times and say he does it because he wants to win and you would dismiss him. But when he helps another player getting back on his feet you say you cannot accept it. A little contradictory IMO.
 
ONLY hardwork is lackinh. I had Chris Waddle say on ethe BBC a couple of years back that the reason United kept sweeping everything is because theyw worked twice as hard as everybody.If We start doing that (i.e remeber our "Second string" victory Chelsea "A" last season?) We will be back in business. I hope fegire can make the lads do that. The chief has spoken :cool: