Kewell or Duff poll

Floyd · Mar 27, 2003

Hold the phone and your horses, I'm not saying that Giggs needs to be replaced or anything like that, but:

If United indeed is going to buy a left midfielder this summer, who do you want it to be, Kewell or Duff?

I'd say Kewell, he scores more goals, can play up front and would probably cost less as Leeds is going down.....

Vinay · Mar 27, 2003

Kewell for me.

beergod · Mar 27, 2003

i would say duff, kewell's attitude sucks

Vinay · Mar 27, 2003

Originally posted by beergod:
i would say duff, kewell's attitude sucks<hr></blockquote>

Nothing SAF would not be able to handle

Hawkeye · Mar 27, 2003

I have a feeling which ever one we sign the other will join the bindippers

alex hurley · Mar 27, 2003

Duff.

Gabe · Mar 27, 2003

Little betweeen them talent wise.

On attitude Duff is better; Kewell's a bit stroppy. Duff is less of a personality to fit in, and a gutsy type that United like, he would blend in easily and it is a team game after all.

Kewell is more physical, Duff gets held back a little by injuries(1651 mins v 2182 for the season).

Kewell would miss some days like Seba on internatinal duty, Duff wouldn't.

If Kewell could settle into the team and accept his role whatever that might be, then I'd take him; he's a little younger and more durable than Duff.
But Duff would be great too, and more likely to accept the role of challenging Giggs for his position, Duff always gives everthing <img src="graemlins/devil.gif" border="0" alt="[Devil]" />

holyland red · Mar 27, 2003

kewell

Gabe · Mar 27, 2003

Originally posted by Hawkeye:
I have a feeling which ever one we sign the other will join the bindippers<hr></blockquote>

Probably, but they'll have to dip into a lot of bins to find money for Duff/Kewell and Cisse.

Billy Blaggs · Mar 27, 2003

Kewell

The only left midfielder in the premiership that can rival Giggs's magic

Floyd · Mar 27, 2003

Originally posted by Billy Blaggs:
Kewell

The only left midfielder in the premiership that can rival Giggs's magic<hr></blockquote>

Let's not forget that the best left midfielder in the premiership is Pires.

Vinay · Mar 27, 2003

Originally posted by Floyd:


Let's not forget that the best left midfielder in the premiership is Pires.<hr></blockquote>

I'll second that. Not a young player, though.

United78 · Mar 27, 2003

Duff -- a United fan as well. Always helps!

Gazza · Mar 27, 2003

Duff - a true red. <img src="graemlins/devil.gif" border="0" alt="[Devil]" />

MauritianRed · Mar 27, 2003

I'll go with Duff. Kewell is too inconsistent.

RedRio · Mar 28, 2003

Duff hasn't done much since the world cup where as Kewell has been scoring left right and center.

Last summer I would have said Duff, but now I would rather have Kewell

Cal? · Mar 28, 2003

Kewell.

Don't want another player suffering from hamstring injuries all the time.

becks_007 · Mar 28, 2003

How old r they?
I'll really have to view my opinion after I c the answer of my question....

jamesblonde · Mar 28, 2003

Marching · Mar 28, 2003

Definately Duff

thumper · Mar 28, 2003

Duff but I would be happy with either to be honest.

Tomo · Mar 28, 2003

Kewell,

SAF will turn the kid into one hell of a footballer <img src="graemlins/devil.gif" border="0" alt="[Devil]" />

MauritianRed · Mar 28, 2003

Originally posted by Tomo:
Kewell,

SAF will turn the kid into one hell of a footballer <img src="graemlins/devil.gif" border="0" alt="[Devil]" /> <hr></blockquote>Oi Tomo how did you manage to get tix for the Seattle game?? The Travel Agent who was organising our trip+tix from calgary to Vancouver/Seattle sold all her allocation the very first day. Worse is I am the fecker who tipped the tart about the game. I am still open for the LA game, but I would lov it, just lov it to go to the Seattle one.

Floyd · Mar 28, 2003

Originally posted by MauritianRed:
I would lov it, just lov it to go to the Seattle one.<hr></blockquote>

Are you Keegan in disguise?

Neil Thomson · Mar 28, 2003

Quaresma for me.

Roy K · Mar 28, 2003

it has to be duff and duff is a liverpool fan not a man united

dmode · Mar 28, 2003

Duff! I've always said so...

dave007 · Mar 30, 2003

Originally posted by marchingontogether:
Definately Duff<hr></blockquote>

Seconded...

and Duff is more determined and works harder according to Champ Man.

maybe I should stop playing Champ Man and go to bed, well it is 5.53am <img src="graemlins/yawn.gif" border="0" alt="[Yawn]" />

becks_007 · Mar 30, 2003

I think Kewell would be a good buy for around 18M!

ANd Quaresmo for around 12M!

Then we'll have to sell Giigz for around 18-20m..

Vinay · Mar 30, 2003

Close count so far -

Kewell 8
Duff 11

Billy Blaggs · Mar 30, 2003

Originally posted by Floyd:


Let's not forget that the best left midfielder in the premiership is Pires.<hr></blockquote>

Disagree I think Pires is more of a free role type of player.
Regardless he is not magic like Giggs and Kewell.

RiO_ iS_WiGgEr_AnD_A_GuN · Mar 30, 2003

kewell easy

Amir · Mar 30, 2003

Originally posted by becks_007:
I think Kewell would be a good buy for around 18M!

ANd Quaresmo for around 12M!

Then we'll have to sell Giigz for around 18-20m..<hr></blockquote>

I don't expect 12 or 20 millions will be flying around this summer so easily.

RedBelly · Mar 30, 2003

Originally posted by RedRio:
Duff hasn't done much since the world cup where as Kewell has been scoring left right and center.

Last summer I would have said Duff, but now I would rather have Kewell<hr></blockquote>

he's scored 3 in his last 3 matches and has had a few injuries this year.

I could see Kewell having a strop and insisting he plays in a certain position or he's off to Real Madrid, and I could see Duff turning into a true red...so for me it's the Duffer.

LenSharkey · Mar 30, 2003

kewell and duff can do one. queresma would be cheaper than both then we can buy kewell and duff to shine his boots

Member 5225 · Mar 30, 2003

I'll prob have to go with Kewell, because he is much more experienced, proved himself in the Premiership and can play-up front too...
IMO Duff is too immature and injury-prone...

So, Kewell for me...

MadDogg · Mar 31, 2003

Originally posted by RedBelly:

I could see Kewell having a strop and insisting he plays in a certain position or he's off to Real Madrid,<hr></blockquote>

He hasn't done that at Leeds (where he would have more bargaining power). He's been happy to play as the link-man and as a full blown striker as well as on the left, and has performed well everywhere.

Kewell gets my vote. As a left mid I rate them both about the same, but Kewell has the advantage of playing well as the extra striker so would give us a bit more versatility. I'm also a bit worried about Duff injury-wise.

yogi · Mar 31, 2003

HARRY

Red Indian Chief Torn Rubber · Mar 31, 2003

Kewell becasue he is more comfortable upfront and is a far better driibler. Even than Giggsy

Slippy · Apr 1, 2003

Quaresma

..But if it´s between Duff and Kewell it must be Kewell just cause he scores more.

Kewell or Duff poll

Doesn't like his Tagline played with

Muppet in Training

Full Member

Muppet in Training

Full Member

New Member

Full Member

"Holier-than-thou fundamentalist"

Full Member

Flacco of the Blaggs tribe

Doesn't like his Tagline played with

Muppet in Training

Full Member

Full Member

Full Member

RedRio

Guest

CR7 fan

New Member

Full Member

Somehow still supports Leeds

thumper

Guest

New Member

Full Member

Doesn't like his Tagline played with

New Member

Roy K

Guest

Full Member

Proud Squareballer

New Member

Muppet in Training

Flacco of the Blaggs tribe

RiO_ iS_WiGgEr_AnD_A_GuN

Guest

Full Member

Full Member

New Member

Member 5225

Guest

Full Member

Workshy Slacker

Thus says Kemo

New Member