Keanos book review

zippy

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Aug 15, 1999
Messages
2,423
Location
Rainbow
bought the book the day it came out and have read it cover to cover. Here's what i got from it;

in the book roy gives us an account of how he became a footballer; the ups and downs of being rejected as a kid as being to small, then finally getting his chance with forest. this is mildly good reading but i think a lot of footballers have similiar stories to tell.
He goes on to tell of his progression with forest and mentions some of the games he took part in, even at this early stage of his career, he was starting to sniff out players without commitment. Stuart Pearce had a huge influence on him, roy obviously still has huge respect for pearce whom he calls the ultimate proffesional.
Eventually roy reaches the part where he signed for manchester united, something i didnt know (or had forgotten) was that he had agreed to sign for blackburn but dogleash had forgotten the paperwork! fergie called him the next day and signed him up! dogleash went off his head! good reading!.
Also roy gives accounts of his time in the irish team from the days when 'big jack' was in charge; it was obvious that the irish setup was a joke for years and roy calls the whole irish setup a bit like the 'carry on' films. later in the book he gives a full account of the world cup shambles in which again the irish f.a had managed to turn into a joke, although in truth roy was partly to blame to which he openly admits in the book.
There are revelations of his drinking and some of the trouble he got himself into - non of it really all that shocking. There are also references to the united team losing their commitment after the treble was won - which still seems to be going on if you ask me.

All in all the book is well worth reading. Once you've read it you will understand that keane is a winner, he is driven to go flat out all the time and does not accept anything less from those around him. He believes in proper preperation for games, he believes in never giving up and he will never lose his principles. He holds his hands up when hes wrong, and refuses to get complacent when goals are scored and trophys are won. He has played through the pain barrier out of the desire to win.

At the end of the day all he wants is a 100% commited united team and for the Irish football league to get its act together properly. its not a lot to ask and roy should definitely not be critisized for wanting those things.

I was unsure what to make of roy before i read the book but now im behind him 100%.
 
Im in the middle of reading it too. Found this part quite funny.

"The 1991-1992 season ended with the Irish squad at a post season friendly international tournament in the United States. This seemed a meaningless exercise, part competitive, part piss-up, in desperately humid conditions. In this sporting limbo -where we here to play or play around? I felt distinctly uneasy. Big Jack was in his element, loving every minute of celebrity, as irish emigrants clamoured for a peice of the man who'd saved the nations football team. I wondered what the hell i was doing here, knackered after a hard season, surrounded by the now familiar chaos of the irish international camp. We lost our first game in the tournament 3-1 to the USA, from there it was downfall all the way.

For some of the Blazers of the football association Ireland this was the life. "the trip of a lifetime" i heard one Blazer gleefully tell another. I felt the football was merely an excuse to justify this "trip of a lifetime" The lads were dog tired at the end of a long season. Nobody seemed to give a damn.

On the morning we were due to fly home, Steve Staunton and I went for a drink. It was our turn to party now - in fact we were merely carrying on from the night before. Merry and Giddy we forgot about the time. We were late arriving back at the team hotel. The rest of the party were sitting in the coach outside. Steve and I raced to our rooms to pack our bags.

As we boarded the coach, Big Jack started ranting and roaring: "where the fecking hell have you been? youve kept us all waiting you two"
"why didnt you go without us?" i shot back. "i didnt ask you to wait" In the silence that followed i looked him straight in the eye. He neither frightened or impressed me. He was a bully who didnt like it when the shoe was on the other foot. He backed off. I took my seat at the back of the bus.
"youre right out of order you" Looking up, i saw Mick McCarthy 'Captain Fantastic' himself, glaring at me.
"Go and feck yourself" i told him.


<img src="graemlins/lol.gif" border="0" alt="[Laugh Out Loud]" /> sort of sums it all up really. no respect for the irish FA & simmering feuds with McCarhty.
 
I'm still in two minds as to buy it or not. I resisted the Stam book, but I don't know about this one.
 
Originally posted by WeasteDevil:
<strong>I'm still in two minds as to buy it or not. I resisted the Stam book, but I don't know about this one.</strong><hr></blockquote>

i think alot of the book you would already know about, the most controversial points have already been brought up in the media and a fair bit is about what i would call a typical footballers life. If what you are really interested in is what happend at the world cup then the last chapter explains it all in his own words, the appendix includes the interview he did that triggered the whole series of events. it basically boiled down to a player (roy) being not happy about the irish world cup organisation/preperation and disliking the manager (mcarthy) for not doing anything about it, and the manager disliking the player for going public (via the interview) prior to the start of the competition with his complaints. Both men where wrong in their actions but mcarthy was more wrong in his inability or unwillingness to 'MANAGE' the situation.

roy would have been better either giving half the profits to charity or just publishing the whole thing on the internet for people to download, the fact that he's going to make a million quid from selling this book is really the only slightly annoying thing about it all...