Keano - Trappings of success dulled United ambition

ShAoLiN_ChRoNiC

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Sep 15, 2001
Messages
1,313
Location
Manchester, England
It pisses me off when fans come out and say something like "We should think about replacing Giggs cos he isnt what he used to be" and someone else comes and says that Giggs is untouchable and will never be replaced. Thats just daft - a players place should never be guaranteed, and some of our stars have definitely lost an edge to their game. Been saying it for ages, and so has Keano:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Roy Keane has blamed his team-mates' passion for "Rolexes, cars and mansions" on Manchester United's failure to win a trophy last season.

The Old Trafford skipper launched a blistering attack on players he claims were no longer "hungry fighters" - and that the glorious treble of 1999 still cast a shadow over the club. And Keane warned another season without success could see some players being shown the exit door.

He said: "There is no way this United team would be allowed to carry on past two years without a trophy. We did a photo shoot on Thursday and I'm not bragging but usually there is something to put at the front of the picture."

He added: "We were looking at the gap and thinking: "We won't be here for this next season if that row is empty again'.

"Last season we didn't grind out results. People used to say we won when we deserved to get beaten. Last season we were just beaten.

"It was the team that leaked goals. The team. Finger-pointing was useless. We weren't hungry fighters anymore.

"That feeling in my gut the night we clinched the treble kept coming back to my mind.

"The champagne was flowing, people were going crazy - but my belief was we had been lucky against a Bayern Munich team that bottled it.

"The following year we won the league by 10 points and Bayern Munich knocked us out of Europe. I felt sick to my heart.

"We should have bought big after the treble, gone for the best, freshened things up, attacked the complacency and let those who didn't care if they never won another trophy join the sort of clubs that don't win any."

The former Republic of Ireland captain - now in the international wilderness following a dispute with boss Mick McCarthy prior to the World Cup - suggested his team-mates had become complacent.

He added in his autobiography, which is being serialised in the News of the World: "By last season, my inkling had become an obsession.

"We'd bought into the glory, our status as heroes and living legends.

"As we stood for the UEFA anthem before the second leg of the Champions Cup semi-final with Bayer Leverkusen, one of our players was shaking.

"He was afraid. Played for his country, won championships, big star - afraid of taking the step up."

He continued: "Blame Seba (Juan Sebastian Veron) - it's too easy. Some of the others were getting away with murder. Glory, believing the publicity, had cost us.

"Rolex watches, garages full of cars, mansions, set up for life - then forgot about the game and lost the hunger that got you the Rolex, the cars and the mansion."

Keane also revealed he almost quit United in the wake of their 4-3 defeat at Newcastle last season - but carried on for manager Sir Alex Ferguson.

Keane was sent off after a tussle with Alan Shearer in the St James" Park defeat in September - and in bed that night he decided to take action.

He said: "I went to bed but never slept a wink.

"Some time during the night I decided `give it up Roy. You've turned 30 - get out, get away, do something else'.

"`You've got to stop hurting yourself, hurting those you love'.

"I talked to my wife. She argued I would miss it. I said I wouldn't. Anything would be better than this madness, getting angry and frustrated, lashing out.

"I felt I'd lost the argument that some players were in the comfort zone. Too many people were content with what they had. It wasn't for me. I should go.

"Next morning I was waiting for Sir Alex Ferguson at the training ground at 8am. I told him I wanted to pack it in. He said it was a knee-jerk reaction."

Keane revealed the duo talked for a long time and he told Ferguson he would not play in the next game - the Champions League clash with Lille - but a walk with his dog changed the picture.

He continued: "On Sunday I walked Triggs a long way, running the options through my head. Another club, somewhere sunny. At least I could be miserable in a warm climate.

"I love my football, really loved it - but could I play for another club? My heart was in Manchester United.

"And if I couldn't play with my heart I couldn't play. My mind was settled. I felt calm - a big weight off my shoulders."

"I thought about it and talked it through with her. I decided to play against Lille.

"He (Ferguson) had stood by me - quitting would be a slap in the face for him - the last thing he needed when the club was struggling. I carried on for him.

"I've got another four years in me - I'm sure of that now."
 
Originally posted by ShAoLiN_ChRoNiC:
<strong>and so has Keano:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Roy Keane has blamed his team-mates' passion for "Rolexes, cars and mansions" on Manchester United's failure to win a trophy last season.

The Old Trafford skipper launched a blistering attack on players he claims were no longer "hungry fighters" - and that the glorious treble of 1999 still cast a shadow over the club. And Keane warned another season without success could see some players being shown the exit door.

He said: "There is no way this United team would be allowed to carry on past two years without a trophy. We did a photo shoot on Thursday and I'm not bragging but usually there is something to put at the front of the picture."

He added: "We were looking at the gap and thinking: "We won't be here for this next season if that row is empty again'.

"Last season we didn't grind out results. People used to say we won when we deserved to get beaten. Last season we were just beaten.

"It was the team that leaked goals. The team. Finger-pointing was useless. We weren't hungry fighters anymore.

"That feeling in my gut the night we clinched the treble kept coming back to my mind.

"The champagne was flowing, people were going crazy - but my belief was we had been lucky against a Bayern Munich team that bottled it.

"The following year we won the league by 10 points and Bayern Munich knocked us out of Europe. I felt sick to my heart.

"We should have bought big after the treble, gone for the best, freshened things up, attacked the complacency and let those who didn't care if they never won another trophy join the sort of clubs that don't win any."

The former Republic of Ireland captain - now in the international wilderness following a dispute with boss Mick McCarthy prior to the World Cup - suggested his team-mates had become complacent.

He added in his autobiography, which is being serialised in the News of the World: "By last season, my inkling had become an obsession.

"We'd bought into the glory, our status as heroes and living legends.

"As we stood for the UEFA anthem before the second leg of the Champions Cup semi-final with Bayer Leverkusen, one of our players was shaking.

"He was afraid. Played for his country, won championships, big star - afraid of taking the step up."

He continued: "Blame Seba (Juan Sebastian Veron) - it's too easy. Some of the others were getting away with murder. Glory, believing the publicity, had cost us.

"Rolex watches, garages full of cars, mansions, set up for life - then forgot about the game and lost the hunger that got you the Rolex, the cars and the mansion."

"I felt I'd lost the argument that some players were in the comfort zone. Too many people were content with what they had. It wasn't for me. I should go.

"."</strong><hr></blockquote>

What was Fergie's attitude at the time to all this. Was he aware that some of his team were in the comfort zone and no longer hungry enough ? If so why didn't he do anything about it - or didn't he agree with Roy ?
 
I think one of the main reasons to get Veron was to increase the competition for places, keep them kean and make them fight for their place.
 
I dont se the wisdom of releasing these autobiographies just before the start of the season. They are sensational and destablising, I just don't get it. :(
 
Roy will always speak his mind, and I tend to trust what comes out of his mouth. He won't pull his punches to keep the peace, fair play to him.

Certain aspects of these books are always pulled out in this way and can be taken out of context. This is exactly what happened with Stam last year. Without reading the whole book I don't like to comment on Keane's attitude to his team mates from one extract.
 
Originally posted by SOCALRED:
<strong>I dont se the wisdom of releasing these autobiographies just before the start of the season. They are sensational and destablising, I just don't get it. :( </strong><hr></blockquote>

Agree with you entirely. Look at the trouble caused by Stam's book and indeed Fergie's. There should be something written into players and Manager's contracts prohibiting them from writing such books during the course of their careers. Probably unsustainable in law unfortuantely.
 
Originally posted by Julian Denny:
Agree with you entirely. Look at the trouble caused by Stam's book and indeed Fergie's. There should be something written into players and Manager's contracts prohibiting them from writing such books during the course of their careers. Probably unsustainable in law unfortuantely.
<hr></blockquote>

I think I read somewhere that after the Stam mess that it was inserted in the players' contracts or at the very least they have to ok the idea of writing a book with Fergie first ... so if Keano's book is published ...
 
Originally posted by United78:
<strong>

I think I read somewhere that after the Stam mess that it was inserted in the players' contracts or at the very least they have to ok the idea of writing a book with Fergie first ... so if Keano's book is published ...</strong><hr></blockquote>

As obvious from what Keane wrote in the paragraphs published, it's obvious he and Fergie are close. Whether it's in his contract or not, I'm sure he talked to the manager about this.
 
Spot on Davo. It's not as though they need the cash is it. It can only be an ego trip if you ask me.
 
What good has come out of these latest revelations?

Your fans will no doubt take the "Gotta love Keane..speaks his mind, heart on his shirt etc etc" approach

Fans of all the other teams will simply find this amusing...he sounds on the edge to me

He could have waited his "3 or 4 years" and then published it..
 
If there's one person who's been taken in by the trappings of success, it's ROY himself.
He's forgotten his roots. The FAI serve cheese sandwiches the night before the Holland away game, and it's seen by Keane as an excuse to quit Ireland?!?! I mean, everybody knows how unprofessional the FAI are, but that is ridiculous. He's like the alco who's given up booze, and now nobody round him can drink. Complete hypocrite, when you consider the crap he got up to when he was younger. And I despise the way he sold out Ian Harte and Jason McAteer at the world cup, telling that they were on his side but afraid to say anything to McCarthy.
One word, hypocrite.

From a huge Man Utd & Ireland supporter.

Btw, we have averaged one Keane conversation every 2 days in our house and in Ireland consensus is going strongly against Keano (except for the Celtic supporters who make up a lot of Irish fans).
 
Originally posted by jamesblonde:
<strong>If there's one person who's been taken in by the trappings of success, it's ROY himself.
He's forgotten his roots. The FAI serve cheese sandwiches the night before the Holland away game, and it's seen by Keane as an excuse to quit Ireland?!?! I mean, everybody knows how unprofessional the FAI are, but that is ridiculous. He's like the alco who's given up booze, and now nobody round him can drink. Complete hypocrite, when you consider the crap he got up to when he was younger. And I despise the way he sold out Ian Harte and Jason McAteer at the world cup, telling that they were on his side but afraid to say anything to McCarthy.
One word, hypocrite.

From a huge Man Utd & Ireland supporter.

Btw, we have averaged one Keane conversation every 2 days in our house and in Ireland consensus is going strongly against Keano (except for the Celtic supporters who make up a lot of Irish fans).</strong><hr></blockquote>

As a "huge Man Utd" supporter where is all that anti Keane angst leading you to, I wonder ?
 
Originally posted by United78:
<strong>

I think I read somewhere that after the Stam mess that it was inserted in the players' contracts or at the very least they have to ok the idea of writing a book with Fergie first ... so if Keano's book is published ...</strong><hr></blockquote>

This time it is different from Stam's case. Keano has the full backing of Fergie. Yes he critized his teammates again in the book, but so what? He has already done it a dozen time by speaking, the only difference this time is he do it by writing instead.

I agree with Shaolin that there should not be any player who is untouchable. No player is bigger than the club and there is absolutely no problem to critize a player, given that the critize is backuped with evidence and facts.
 
Btw, we have averaged one Keane conversation every 2 days in our house and in Ireland consensus is going strongly against Keano (except for the Celtic supporters who make up a lot of Irish fans).
<hr></blockquote>

Stop talking shite, depends on who you hang around with, where your from, who you support, etc, etc....
There has been no proper poll taken on the Keane issue. There is no consensus and why the feck should a consensus matter... Is there somebody up for election here ??

You seem to think the rights and wrongs of this come down to where you believe the majority is at.
Baaaaaaa Baaaaaaa Baaaaaaaa
 
Originally posted by jamesblonde:
<strong>Btw, we have averaged one Keane conversation every 2 days in our house and in Ireland consensus is going strongly against Keano (except for the Celtic supporters who make up a lot of Irish fans).</strong><hr></blockquote>so what? my dad and brother talk about keano everyday at home in Ireland and they say that everyone they know is on keano's side. funny how there's a difference of opinion from place to place isn't it?

<img src="graemlins/smirk.gif" border="0" alt="[Smirk]" />
 
I read somewhere a while ago that Keane gave his book to SAF and Michael Kennedy to proof read...so that a repeat of the Stam episode would not happen....
 
Keane is simply saying it how he sees it....the FAI are a shower of second rate crooks obsessed with lining their own pockets.He has to go from Man Utd to a badly run organization who ndon't care about Football.Who can blame him for speaking out.
McCarthy is a poor manager and Ireland always get as far as they got in the World Cup on emotion anyway.