Herr Musk | Fascist

Isn't this the man who has to go on a tour of Auschwitz because he was accused of not doing enough to fight antisemitism on his social media site? Now he's suddenly Pro Israel?

Make it make sense!

He literally did it to appease Israel. IIRC, he went on a tour of a Kibbutz, and spent a lot of time in Israel going to far-right politicians parties and such.

Which is pretty ironic given Islamaphobia and Antisemitism are both pretty much unchecked and rampant in X.
 
Yes, because he's a trolling wanker who thinks real life in a 2005 4Chan message board where he can get away with all sorts of fecked up "edgy humour."

Not because he's genuinely a massive supporter of the third reich...
You don't think that the guy who supports every ultra right wing operations in Europe, including Nazis, a guy who grew up in a pro-apartheid household, a guy who was literally named after a Nazi, does a Nazi salute publicly...you don't believe that guy could be a Nazi?

The guy is telling you he's a Nazi. Why even bother giving him the benefit of the doubt? Treat the cnut like the Nazi he is.
 
I think people are way over-reacting to this.

IMO he's just a trolly edgelord "4chan humour" who thinks he can get away with internet-esque trolling/LARP behaviour in real life because he's a billionaire.

Which, doesn't make him in any way less of a knob head, but I have very little indication to believe he's genuinely pro Nazism.

Cannot really reconcile him being a Nazi and also being heavily pro-Israel.

You seem to be overly hung up on the literal definition of Nazi as the Hitler collective, just replace that word with fascist, it’s just a synonym these days.
 
He literally did it to appease Israel. IIRC, he went on a tour of a Kibbutz, and spent a lot of time in Israel going to far-right politicians parties and such.

Which is exactly my point. The same as Trump banging on about how Jewish voters will cost him the election but taking $100 million from Miriam......
 
Yes, because he's a trolling wanker who thinks real life in a 2005 4Chan message board where he can get away with all sorts of fecked up "edgy humour."

Not because he's genuinely a massive supporter of the third reich...
Just a supporter of Germany's current far right party, run by the granddaughter of a Nazi judge appointed by Hitler himself.

It's amazing how everything he does always seems to be for a reason other than he's simply a fascist supporting dickhead.
 
You don't think that the guy who supports every ultra right wing operations in Europe, including Nazis, a guy who grew up in a pro-apartheid household, a guy who was literally named after a Nazi, does a Nazi salute publicly...you don't believe that guy could be a Nazi?

The guy is telling you he's a Nazi. Why even bother giving him the benefit of the doubt? Treat the cnut like the Nazi he is.

I haven't dug deep into the background history of Elon Musk's family, but from what I did read, it was mostly his gramps who was a Aparthied Loving Right Wing extremist right but he died when Elon could barely walk.

I've encountered people like Elon Musk before - both online and in real life. Miserable sods/Narcissists who just constantly crave attention so they go for the most controversial / "edgiest" / twitchiest views out there, not because they actually believe them but because it gets them attention. No attention is bad attention and all that shite.
Genuinely think Elon Musk just took this shite into real life on a mass scale because he thinks he's immune to accountability and consequence - which for the most part unfortunately isn't wrong.

I'm not defending him by the way - he's a massive cnut and a gigantic piece of shite. World would be a better place without him. But it will take more than a Nazi salute from a known shit-stirring troll to convince me he genuinely is a Nazi.
 
I haven't dug deep into the background history of Elon Musk's family, but from what I did read, it was mostly his gramps who was a Aparthied Loving Right Wing extremist right but he died when Elon could barely walk.

I've encountered people like Elon Musk before - both online and in real life. Miserable sods/Narcissists who just constantly crave attention so they go for the most controversial / "edgiest" / twitchiest views out there, not because they actually believe them but because it gets them attention. No attention is bad attention and all that shite.
Genuinely think Elon Musk just took this shite into real life on a mass scale because he thinks he's immune to accountability and consequence - which for the most part unfortunately isn't wrong.

I'm not defending him by the way - he's a massive cnut and a gigantic piece of shite. World would be a better place without him. But it will take more than a Nazi salute from a known shit-stirring troll to convince me he genuinely is a Nazi.
Ok but why does he need to convince you? Why are you trying to decipher his intentions for yourself? Why not just take him what he is at face value? A troll? Yes. A troll who's also a Nazi? That's what he's telling us. Checks out with his Hitler rhetoric, holocaust denial and supporting right wing parties with money and public declarations, including the Nazi ones.

Have you encountered these same people in real life? People who behave like him and put money where their mouth is?
 
You seem to be overly hung up on the literal definition of Nazi as the Hitler collective, just replace that word with fascist, it’s just a synonym these days.

I reckon even “fascist” means something different nowadays. It’s become a synonym for small government, libertarian, white supremacists. Like I keep saying, I’m pretty clueless at history and politics but don’t think it’s always meant that particular point on the political spectrum?
 
Ok but why does he need to convince you? Why are you trying to decipher his intentions for yourself? Why not just take him what he is at face value? A troll? Yes. A troll who's also a Nazi? That's what he's telling us. Checks out with his Hitler rhetoric, holocaust denial and supporting right wing parties with money and public declarations, including the Nazi ones.

Have you encountered these same people in real life? People who behave like him and put money where their mouth is?

If he is genuinely a Nazi, it will mean the top level of government in the Western World, holding together "Western values", is no longer a paradigm I would ever wish to subscribe to. Furthermore, if it comes out that he is, what I strive towards and my goals and belief system will have to shift completely. My life too. It's important to me.

Maybe a day will come when he it turns out this administration are all genuine "Fascists," whatever definition you want to fetch from that. If that is a case, I will quit my job and never set foot in the United States again.
 
Yes, because he's a trolling wanker who thinks real life in a 2005 4Chan message board where he can get away with all sorts of fecked up "edgy humour."

Not because he's genuinely a massive supporter of the third reich...
Have you been living in a cave for the last year regarding Musk?
 
If he is genuinely a Nazi, it will mean the top level of government in the Western World, holding together "Western values", is no longer a paradigm I would ever wish to subscribe to. Furthermore, if it comes out that he is, what I strive towards and my goals and belief system will have to shift completely. My life too. It's important to me.

Maybe a day will come when he it turns out this administration are all genuine "Fascists," whatever definition you want to fetch from that. If that is a case, I will quit my job and never set foot in the United States again.
That's pretty much what's happening isn't it? What values do you see that you align with? The fascism? The women oppression? The oligarchy?
 
Ok but why does he need to convince you? Why are you trying to decipher his intentions for yourself? Why not just take him what he is at face value? A troll? Yes. A troll who's also a Nazi? That's what he's telling us. Checks out with his Hitler rhetoric, holocaust denial and supporting right wing parties with money and public declarations, including the Nazi ones.

Have you encountered these same people in real life? People who behave like him and put money where their mouth is?

Yeah, guy in military joined the BNP and donated money to them for "banter." Bragged to everyone about it. Voted Lib Dem since he was legally allowed to vote and all his political views that were public were that of a boring centrist when you actually talk to him about things. Obviously, since he thought it was hilarious and bragged to everyone about it, he got discharged. Legit attention seeking wanker.
 
I think people are way over-reacting to this.

IMO he's just a trolly edgelord "4chan humour" who thinks he can get away with internet-esque trolling/LARP behaviour in real life because he's a billionaire.

Which, doesn't make him in any way less of a knob head, but I have very little indication to believe he's genuinely pro Nazism.

Cannot really reconcile him being a Nazi and also being heavily pro-Israel.

You've really not being paying attention at all, have you?
 
That's pretty much what's happening isn't it? What values do you see that you align with? The fascism? The women oppression? The oligarchy?
It's exactly what's happening. It's either through willful ignorance or cognitive dissonance that they can't see it. It's happening, people need to come to terms with it. Especially if we're going to have any chance of defeating it
 
That's pretty much what's happening isn't it? What values do you see that you align with? The fascism? The women oppression? The oligarchy?

the top level of government is not the executive branch. The top level of governance that holds the day to day together, are the various structures and departments that hold the current American and Western system together. State department, DoD, Treasury, Interior etc.

Regardless of who you throw at the Director/Secretary positions, at the execution level the system remains somewhat apolitical. Which is necessary - much like the Civil Service split in the UK.

Now, things are not going well. Trump has already pledged to get rid of "traitors" within these departments, it hasn't happened "yet." You have shit like project 25 to put in Christian-Fascist civil servants in these day to day positions. It hasn't happened...yet.

Lets wait and see - but I agree the trajectory does not look good.

If it turns out the biggest Republican/MAGA benefactor is indeed a Nazi, or the "purge" of apolitical civil servants in the federal government does occur, then yes, it's the beginning of the end and I shall not offer myself to this bastardization of a system.
 
I reckon even “fascist” means something different nowadays. It’s become a synonym for small government, libertarian, white supremacists. Like I keep saying, I’m pretty clueless at history and politics but don’t think it’s always meant that particular point on the political spectrum?
Definitely not. Small government and libertarian has got nothing to do with the modern day accusations of fascism leveled at Trump. It's more the extreme nationalism, making the media the enemy, general totalitarianism, traditional sex and gender roles, and direct political action and violence.
 
You've really not being paying attention at all, have you?
Have you been living in a cave for the last year regarding Musk?

Can someone ELI5 me Musk has said/done in the past year? Specifically the Nazism/Fascism part?

I've followed to the point of "Musk says dumb thing", "Musk is funding Trump and threatening to fund primaries against GOP who aren't pro Trump", "Musk promotes DOGE", "Musk promotes H1B", "Musk promotes Reform Party and doesn't like Farage" .
 
Some would still say that is not facism/nazism even if a night of the broken glass would happen in their neighbourhood because it didn't happen to jews but to another collective

How some people can't see towards where the US is walking towards is beyond me. Is just a matter if the institutions will hold (and I don't know how)
 
Can someone ELI5 me Musk has said/done in the past year? Specifically the Nazism/Fascism part?

I've followed to the point of "Musk says dumb thing", "Musk is funding Trump and threatening to fund primaries against GOP who aren't pro Trump", "Musk promotes DOGE", "Musk promotes H1B", "Musk promotes Reform Party and doesn't like Farage" .

I don't know if there is the same saying in english but in spanish there is one that says: "Tell me with you are you walking and I will tell you who you are"

AdF, Tommy Robbins, and many other fascist/nazist personalities and institutions that he has praised and promoted. Being for conviction, being for economical gains he is a fascist/nazist as the same that they benefit from nazism in the 30s/40s by conviction and/or benefit. All of them are contributed to the success (and downfall) of nazism as Musk is doing right now
 
I think people are way over-reacting to this.

IMO he's just a trolly edgelord "4chan humour" who thinks he can get away with internet-esque trolling/LARP behaviour in real life because he's a billionaire.

Which, doesn't make him in any way less of a knob head, but I have very little indication to believe he's genuinely pro Nazism.

Cannot really reconcile him being a Nazi and also being heavily pro-Israel.
Well if you look at the evidence ie the conduct of Nazis in and the conduct of Israeli ultra nationalists, then it is clear there isn’t much distinction between them.
 
Yes, because he's a trolling wanker who thinks real life in a 2005 4Chan message board where he can get away with all sorts of fecked up "edgy humour."

Not because he's genuinely a massive supporter of the third reich...
You're massively overstating just how much of a practical difference does that make.
 
Can someone ELI5 me Musk has said/done in the past year? Specifically the Nazism/Fascism part?

I've followed to the point of "Musk says dumb thing", "Musk is funding Trump and threatening to fund primaries against GOP who aren't pro Trump", "Musk promotes DOGE", "Musk promotes H1B", "Musk promotes Reform Party and doesn't like Farage" .
Without compiling a long-list, most recently he's been cozying up to the AfD in Germany. This is far-right political party with some seriously troubling links to neo-Nazis in their own ranks. In 2024 there was a big scandal about high-ranking members of the AfD meeting with literal neo-Nazis to discuss deportation plans and other things. This is a party that, according to Musk, is the only one that can save Germany. Appearing in a podcast with co-chairwoman of the party they agreed on the old trope that Hitler was actually socialist.
 
I don't know if there is the same saying in english but in spanish there is one that says: "Tell me with you are you walking and I will tell you who you are"

AdF, Tommy Robbins, and many other fascist/nazist personalities and institutions that he has praised and promoted. Being for conviction, being for economical gains he is a fascist/nazist as the same that they benefit from nazism in the 30s/40s by conviction and/or benefit. All of them are contributed to the success (and downfall) of nazism as Musk is doing right now

You mean Tommy Robinson? As in EDL Tommy Robinson?

Wtf How does Elon Musk even know who Tommy Robinson is.

I don't think ADF is particularly grating - especially since these days MAGA/GOP are more right wing than the AFD - especially on social policies. I'd imagine that one who subscribes to Trump will naturally tend towards AFD. Nevertheless, if you think the current MAGA is close to Fascism/Nazism then it makes sense to think the same for AFD. I don't think we are there...yet.

None of this paints a great picture but it will become clear in a few months.

Lets wait and see - the US institutions have suffered through bigger crises than this and came out unscathed. One can only hope.
 
You mean Tommy Robinson? As in EDL Tommy Robinson?

Wtf How does Elon Musk even know who Tommy Robinson is.

I don't think ADF is particularly grating - especially since these days MAGA/GOP are more right wing than the AFD - especially on social policies. I'd imagine that one who subscribes to Trump will naturally tend towards AFD. Nevertheless, if you think the current MAGA is close to Fascism/Nazism then it makes sense to think the same for AFD. I don't think we are there...yet.

None of this paints a great picture but it will become clear in a few months.

Lets wait and see - the US institutions have suffered through bigger crises than this and came out unscathed. One can only hope.
Give it a few years. They are tracked for right wing extremism by German intelligence in several German states
 
Without compiling a long-list, most recently he's been cozying up to the AfD in Germany. This is far-right political party with some seriously troubling links to neo-Nazis in their own ranks. In 2024 there was a big scandal about high-ranking members of the AfD meeting with literal neo-Nazis to discuss deportation plans and other things. This is a party that, according to Musk, is the only one that can save Germany. Appearing in a podcast with co-chairwoman of the party they agreed on the old trope that Hitler was actually socialist.

I'm not too disturbed by AFD links given MAGA have well exceeded them in Right-wing-ness. But if you think MAGA has already crossed the threshold for Fascism then it makes sense to think that for AFD too.

Regarding the bold - Ugh for feck sake. It's classic right wing bullshit to try to cleanse the palate and whitewash themselves from Hitler with the whole "BUT HE WAS LEFT WING" nonsense.

Incidentally, there was a very good WWII historian on Youtube called TIK who posted incredibly detailed content on esoterric battles in WWII, until he went with the whole "Hitler was a socialist" shite and then doubled down and tripled double on it until he was basically cancelled by his own viewers and subscribers.

None of this paints a good picture, I will say.
 
Definitely not. Small government and libertarian has got nothing to do with the modern day accusations of fascism leveled at Trump. It's more the extreme nationalism, making the media the enemy, general totalitarianism, traditional sex and gender roles, and direct political action and violence.

We’re talking about Musk though, not Trump. And small government/libertarianism is 100% Musk’s political inclinations. Him and all the other tech bros.
 
You mean Tommy Robinson? As in EDL Tommy Robinson?

Wtf How does Elon Musk even know who Tommy Robinson is.

I don't think ADF is particularly grating - especially since these days MAGA/GOP are more right wing than the AFD - especially on social policies. I'd imagine that one who subscribes to Trump will naturally tend towards AFD. Nevertheless, if you think the current MAGA is close to Fascism/Nazism then it makes sense to think the same for AFD. I don't think we are there...yet.

None of this paints a great picture but it will become clear in a few months.

Lets wait and see - the US institutions have suffered through bigger crises than this and came out unscathed. One can only hope.

Yes, Robinson. My Bad

https://www.politico.eu/article/elon-musk-fund-uk-far-right-ringleader-tommy-robinson-legal-fight/



And well, I will wait and see because I can do feck all besides not downplaying what is happening. But do the people that can do something have the luxury to wait and see (if it is not too late already)?
 
I'm not too disturbed by AFD links given MAGA have well exceeded them in Right-wing-ness. But if you think MAGA has already crossed the threshold for Fascism then it makes sense to think that for AFD too.

Regarding the bold - Ugh for feck sake. It's classic right wing bullshit to try to cleanse the palate and whitewash themselves from Hitler with the whole "BUT HE WAS LEFT WING" nonsense.

Incidentally, there was a very good WWII historian on Youtube called TIK who posted incredibly detailed content on esoterric battles in WWII, until he went with the whole "Hitler was a socialist" shite and then doubled down and tripled double on it until he was basically cancelled by his own viewers and subscribers.

None of this paints a good picture, I will say.
I think the whole "does it cross into Nazism/fascism" debate is a bit of a red herring. It always ends up with meaningless comparisons and people finding differences between the original versions and what we are seeing now. I think MAGA has crossed well over the line of what should be acceptable behavior in the political arena. Reasonable people can disagree on whether it's fascism based on different definitions.

And I do think there is cause for concern when Germany's most far-right party begins chatting with neo-Nazis and making excuses for Hitler. Musk clearly knows this and want to amplify them - make of that what you will.