Fergie's successor

Neil Thomson

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Aug 21, 2001
Messages
13,228
Location
Hippydom
FOOTBALL: KEANE IS A BORN LEADER, HE IS THE NATURAL CHOICE TO FOLLOW SIR ALEX SAYS RUUD VAN NISTELROOY
RUUD Van Nistelrooy believes Manchester United should abandon their worldwide search to find a long-term successor to Sir Alex Ferguson and offer the job to club captain Roy Keane.

The Dutch striker claims Keane has all the qualities needed to succeed Ferguson and the drive and respect to maintain success at Old Trafford.

In one of the frankest interviews of his career Van Nistelrooy lifts the lid on life at United.

He reveals that homesickness almost wrecked his Old Trafford career, how David Beckham gets embarrassed by his celebrity lifestyle, how United players are allowed to play cards for money, and how he struggles to come to terms with the fabulous wealth that goes hand in hand with playing for the world's biggest clubs.

On the field Keane is already established as one of the best leaders of his generation and, while controversy is rarely two paces behind the Irishman, Van Nistelrooy believes there is no one better qualified to replace Ferguson when he eventually retires.

He said: "Nobody else has more qualities for the manager's job than Roy and I forecast that he will be the manager of United before long.

"If he is not the number one man for the future he should be and I think quite a few players believe he is the natural successor to the manager.

"Roy is already a real leader, the boss in our squad. He is above anyone else in the group and every player accepts that.

"He is very dominating, from the minute he walks into the dressing-room or through the front door. He throws his weight about and he takes all the decisions in the squad.

"And that's why Roy will become a fantastic manager. He has all the qualities a manager needs. His football ideas and his vision are incredible, both on and off the pitch.

"He doesn't suffer fools easily and tells players off immediately when they are not doing the business for the team whether they are on the pitch or the training field.

"I like Roy a lot. I am really pro-Keane. Of course he has done a few daft things in his career but he knows that better than anyone else. He is the working-class hero and that makes him so popular at Old Trafford."

Van Nistelrooy also reveals for the first time how homesickness nearly destroyed his United career.

"It sounds daft, but I missed my own country like mad and I was really struggling to settle in the first season. As soon as I got off a plane in Amsterdam, it felt as if a massive weight had fallen off my shoulders.

"I was so relieved to be back home and there were times when I wondered if I could drag myself back, if I'd made a mistake in leaving Holland.

"I bought my own house in a little village called Heesch, because my girlfriend Leontien and I wanted to have our own place back in Holland. I know I am not a cosmopolitan, I am a real Dutchman and always will be.

"Fortunately the feeling of being homesick is going. Last year every single day off I used to go back home. Honestly, I was on the plane all the time. So far this season I have not been back once."

Van Nistelrooy also claims that David Beckham is embarrassed by his public image and cringes whenever he's on TV.

He said: "David has superstar status and in the eye of the public is a real celebrity. That is his image, created by his wife and because of his looks. But it is not the David Beckham I know as a team-mate. He is the most modest lad of all in our squad.

"It sounds stupid, but David is shy and quiet. He does not want to attract all the limelight when we play or train.

"And he hates to see himself on television. He quickly switches to another channel when he is on the box in a hotel or at the club. He really does not want to see it, he feels so embarrassed."

The Dutch striker admits that training at United has taken him by surprise but he reveals that Fergie never takes a session - and claims the players have dubbed him The Hawk because he never misses a thing.

"We don't do any easy stuff like passing, cross passing and easy stuff like that. When you sign for United you have to be so talented that this part of your game should be perfect already.

"Alex Ferguson never takes us training. He walks around all the time and he hears and sees everything. He watches us train, he gives advice, talks to players individually and gives them a telling-off or he pats someone on the back.

"He never misses a thing. The players call him The Hawk because nothing goes unnoticed. If you go to the toilet he knows about it."

But Fergie is not a tyrant and he couldn't care less if his players lose all their money at cards if they win on Saturday.

"The boss is very relaxed, he does not order us to wear the same suits or gear. We can all wear what we want, we don't have to report for breakfast at a certain time when we're in a hotel and we can have a lie-in when we want or even have breakfast in the room.

"Sir Alex does not care too much as long as we win. In the rest of Europe this would be impossible. But Sir Alex even lets us take family on the players' coach on the way back. It makes things so much more relaxed.

"The players spend a lot of time travelling. Oh, and maybe I shouldn't say this but a lot of them play cards.

"Yes, they play for money. I can see them writing stuff down all the time when they are playing. They play on the train when we go to London, in hotels or on the plane and the manager is fine as long as he is winning.

"But I don't want to be a hypocrite, they can afford it. If you play in the first team at United, your wages are astronomical.

"Honestly, what we earn is not just a whacking amount of money by Dutch standards, it's obscene when you compare it to what is earned in the rest of Europe.

"As a player you choose a club and you pick the ideal country where you want to play, but I admit that the size of your wage packet plays a major part."

Yet it doesn't stop Van Nistelrooy leading a normal life.

"The supporters don't care how much we earn as long as we are successful. I have always found them very polite

"If I go out for dinner, they leave me in peace until I have finished my meal. When I have paid for the bill they ask me for a signature.

"I enjoy it that I have the chance to go out to restaurants, to the local pub in Bowden and to the cinema, without getting jumped on.

"The only problem I have is going shopping in Manchester. That is really impossible. That's why I don't go any more and the players take the rise out of my clothing. I don't care though, clothes aren't important to me and for all the money I earn I'm not materialistic."

Van Nistelrooy says he has never refused to sign autographs for any kid and every fan, but the players have been told always to ask who it is for to deter collectors looking to make vast amounts of money at their expense.

"The players refuse to sign shirts with just their name on it because those people who ask me that, want to make money.

"I have seen shirts with my own autograph in auctions and on internet for more than £700 and that makes me sick.

"The club have told us to be careful because when you play for Manchester United someone is always going to try to make money out of you.

"I don't need to sell my shirt to make money and I don't see why other people should profit from it.

"If a fan is genuine I will always stop and sign something. Football has given me a life beyond my reach and if I just put a little something back it makes me happy."

From the Mirror.
 
Sounds like a decent down to earth bloke.

Do you reckon Keane would be ready to move straight into the hotseat or spend time as Fergie's assistant first?

It's a massive role to take on with no experience.
 
Originally posted by Neil Thomson:
<strong>RUUD Van Nistelrooy believes Manchester United should abandon their worldwide search to find a long-term successor to Sir Alex Ferguson and offer the job to club captain Roy Keane.

The Dutch striker claims Keane has all the qualities needed to succeed Ferguson and the drive and respect to maintain success at Old Trafford.</strong>

I just can't see the biggest club in the world will have any chance to appoint a manger who has absolutely no club managing experience. Look at Bryan Robson, a legend and a born leader don't essentially make a genius manager. Robson or Keano may return as manger one day, but not before they gain more experience in other lesser clubs.

<strong>
He said: "David has superstar status and in the eye of the public is a real celebrity. That is his image, created by his wife and because of his looks. But it is not the David Beckham I know as a team-mate. He is the most modest lad of all in our squad.

"It sounds stupid, but David is shy and quiet. He does not want to attract all the limelight when we play or train.</strong>

That's not surprising me at all. Watch his games and you can see no matter how many fame, attention he gained, he has changed absolutely nothing in his passion and love for football in these years. He still fight very hard and hate losing like a lad. I still think he will be the one to succeed Keano as the captain of the team.

A good and interesting interview. Glad that Ruud finally overcome his homesick problem and hope he can go on to play more great football for us.
<hr></blockquote>
 
Originally posted by Keano's Mental Demons:
<strong>Sounds like a decent down to earth bloke.

Do you reckon Keane would be ready to move straight into the hotseat or spend time as Fergie's assistant first?

It's a massive role to take on with no experience.</strong><hr></blockquote>

No, keane won't be in the reckoning when the search for the successor to SAF begins, maybe after he gets some experience elsewhere first. Personally, I would love to see a former united player like bruce, robson or hughes be the next manager, but its too risky. Most prob the board will go for an european manager with a proven track record after SAF retires.

btw, thats a GREAT article, Neil.
:)
 
It would be very high risk without any previous managerial experience. Rather let him learn about management somewhere else first and see how many people he upsets, dressing room doors he breaks down and tea cups he smashes. Then again perhaps the latter would be a good indication of future success !
 
hughes seems to be making a good name for himself.

if wales go to Euro Championships i wouldn't cross him out from replacing SAF.
 
Keano would be a great motivator, you can see over the years how fanatical he is about winning.
It was good to hear RVN say 'his football ideas and vision are incredible', because managers have to be creative, not just bossy-there are plently of bossy gits, and that method is limited- managers/coaches IMO need to be constructive more than destructive.
Keano has a great advantage having studied under a master, -he said last summer that he values SAF's opinion over any other in football.
Also he knows how OT works on the inside.
Since Keano is already respected as the boss by all the players, that makes the transition easier if he did eventually take over. But he would need a high level of experience to take over, a top club, playing european football, experience in negotionating big transfers, and so on.
 
Keano and Alex would make a great Coach and Manager partnership, becoming a Coach/Manager and General Manager partnership.
 
Keane may make a great manager but I would like to see him serve his apprenticeship the same way that Fergie did. It gave him a fantastic grounding and Fergie admits himself that the way he came through the managerial ranks helped him become the most successful manager England has ever seen.

You can't expect Keane to take over the biggest club in the world as his first job. I would like to see him stay at old Trafford but work his way up from the Academy. Not all great leader become great managers.

As for a replacement my favourite would be Alex McLeish. He's doing a great job at Rangers and i think he's down to earth enough to be able to handle the extra pressure that a job like United's brings.
 
Originally posted by Fergiesarmy:
<strong>sparky

that would be fantastic, everyone respects him and the fans would love him too</strong><hr></blockquote>
Only managed the welsh national team so far though, not a club, so he's no experience in transfers and little in coaching I'd think.

Keano should over the next few years get more involved in coaching. Although Roy might not have any managerial experience himself, its clear he already has a very large role at OT, and if Alex stayed on as mentor and general manager, then a smooth transition could be made.
 
hes turned wales around from a laughing stock to the next ireland.

i dont think any future manager of united will get as involved anywhere near as much as fergie does in the running of the club ie transfers, staff, etc

he currently uses eric harrison as his coach and im sure there are lots of top coaches out there who would love to work at united.
 
weve got a great coach in quiroz... hughes could be the tactical man who makes it work... anybody who can make a welsh team beat a tem of vieri pirilo del-piero nesta costacurta maldini donati buffon ... he simply must have a good grasp of tactics... he's worked under fergie and has been at barca and byern as well ... hes a true red thru and thru what more do u want?????

HUGHES!!!!!!!!

Sparkey 4 boss!!!
 
Originally posted by Fergiesarmy:
<strong>hes turned wales around from a laughing stock to the next ireland.

i dont think any future manager of united will get as involved anywhere near as much as fergie does in the running of the club ie transfers, staff, etc

he currently uses eric harrison as his coach and im sure there are lots of top coaches out there who would love to work at united.</strong><hr></blockquote>

You've raised a good point- what will be the job for the future manager, because the club is a bigger organisation than the one SAF joined.

Obviously the manager determines the shape of the team, but within certain perameters. Kenyon stated some of the criteria last year- a commitment to youth, and preserving United's brand of entertaining football. So we have a 'winning formula', its not like we need a 'new broom to sweep clean'.
As far as transfers go, how might that change, is SAF more involved in courting players than other managers(plenty of clubs send 'gifts' to prospective employees)? Fergie is said to be a persuasive suitor, surely a manager's blessing would carry a lot of weigh in attracting players.
 
Alan Curbishley anyone?

I know Charlton got dissed at the weekend, but otherwise he gets his team to play a brand of passing football far beyond the abilities of the individual players.

Plus he is quite young and probably can give United a good decade of service before moving on.
Needless to say, I am a big fan of stability.

:)
 
Ah, but what about McLaren,? He has with out a doubt proved his worth at Middlseborough on a shoestring budget.He has all the qualifications,the know how, the set up.
If we don't go and get him back he will come back to haunt us.
I know United were looking at a high profile coach and I really think that Steve has everything to fit the bill.

I read and hear of this coach and that, but lets face it none come higher than SAF. Whoever we get is a step down, lets not kid ourselves he is the best, he HAS proved it.

Steve went to Boro after one of the most gifted coaches there is, in Terry V. Most expected him to fail, he has not or will not. He is one of the most detailed and foreward thinking coaches/Managers there is.

SAF has theeee most utmost respect for him. I personally think he will be a very succesfull coach/manager in the future, I hope it will be for us. Quiroz is an unknown, probally a good back up for a manager, but NOT a manager, a bit like Brian Kidd.

I was a huge advocate of O,Neill, but have been hugely dissapointed in his European games and more so now that Rangers are challenging him domestically.

Keano.? For the future for sure, should be nurtured for the future by United. Would love to see him and McLaren together.

What ever happened to the story that Cantonna would be joining United as a coach.?

As much as we do well in our youth policy, I would like to see us doing the same in the managerial level. Bringing up people to be promoted from within the club.

Look at Liverpool and their succesion of managers that sustained their dominance for so long. It all came from within. So when one manager retired there was already one to take his place. Its not just about the players, its the managers and organization as well, its a well proven fact.
United have had and let go, two of the most respected and knowledgable coaches in the country in Kidd and McLaren. We should have nurtured them for the future, had we done that we would have no problem for the future for many years to come.
 
The way I would go about appointing Fergie's successor is as follows:

Find the man with the credentials and make him Fergie's assistant sharpish, whoever he is. Pay him whatever it takes.

As Fergie IS United, it's important that the new man has time to understand which qualities he needs to inherit and maintain and which qualities of his own he should bring to the table.

At least at first anyway, to make the transition as seamless as possible.

Is it possible Queiroz was appointed with a view to succeeding Sir Alex?
 
Originally posted by Keano's Mental Demons:
<strong>Is it possible Queiroz was appointed with a view to succeeding Sir Alex?</strong><hr></blockquote>

That is possible. His resume has shown enough experience as a manger already. If he does the job well in these three years, he will certainly become one of the contender for the post.
 
If Queroz becomes the manager would it be on a short term basis with Keane/Hughes/McClair as an assistant to learn the ropes with a view to taking over?
 
I'd be surprised if it was Hughesie - there's a massive difference between club and national management. And Wales is still a small team with low expectations - if they win, it's a bonus.

I wouldn't be surprised if Keane became player-manager with SAF moving upstairs - it worked well for Liverpool for 20years. And Keane has studied under two great managers in Clough and Fergie. But Keano would need to take his coaching badges and would need to learn to manage, rather than shout at people.

McLaren looks a good bet but the challenge there will be how he progresses the club from mid-table respectability, where it is now.

Hmm. Glad I am not Kenyon.
 
I like the idea of Hughes as next boss as many others do, but I suspect he's really just a sentimental choice.
 
The most likely scenario, and indeed the most optimistic one, is that Fergie sees out the remainder of his three years and then retires completely rather than moving upstairs to some nondescript position with little or no influence. I see this extension of his current contract as being in lieu of this so-called upstairs position. In such an optimistic scenario, Fergie adds to the many trophies he has won already and goes out in a blaze of glory. During that time the likes of McClaren, O'Neill, Moyes and maybe one or two others prove their worth at their respective clubs and show sufficient aptitude as well as success for a risk to be taken in bringing them in as team manager at United, a job which because of its daunting demands cannot be compared to anything else in football. Hughes may also fall into this category although his results would be judged at national rather than club level, a subtle difference as has already been pointed out. The risk factor for these candidates would be that they are most unlikely to have managed a successful side in European competition by that time, which is one of Kenyon's pre-requisites for a successor. Then you have people like Keane or even McClair and more outrageously perhaps Cantona, who because of their total lack of managerial experience would need to be brought in earlier as has been suggested under the watchful eye of SAF.
I believe a lot depends on what happens this season. A lot of us were airing concerns as to Fergie's future not so long ago. Have all those concerns disappeared now that he appears to have typically done the imposiible and turned the season round by managing to get the team playing somewhere near its true potential? Not completely, I don't think, as the trophies have yet to be handed out. In a worst case and hopefully unlikely scenario, that this season is once again without trophies, I believe, because of the demands on United as a successful football team and business, the Board will be forced to act and that changes will have to be made. In that situation, Fergie could indeed move into a General Manager position for the remaining couple of years, with one of the aforementioned taking over the day to day running of the team itself. On the other hand, because of the necessity to be seen to be doing something with the leats amount of risk, the Board may revert to its original objective and go for proven experience. Let's hope that won't be necessary.
 
I may be wrong but I thought Keano had said he didn't want to go into management. Anyone who's read his book know about this?
 
Whatever happens, it's probably safe to assume that the new man will be brought into the club along side Ferguson in some capacity for a while.

Surely it can't be a good move to appoint someone entirely new once Alex has left?

My guess is that Kenyon & co realised this when Ferguson u-turned and appointed Queiroz.
 
Originally posted by Keano's Mental Demons:
<strong>Whatever happens, it's probably safe to assume that the new man will be brought into the club along side Ferguson in some capacity for a while.
</strong><hr></blockquote>

*ahem* Queiroz . . .

:D
 
Originally posted by Fergiesarmy:
<strong>sparky

that would be fantastic, everyone respects him and the fans would love him too</strong><hr></blockquote>

I'll second that! Sparky is and always will a manchester red!
 
Originally posted by Sydius:
<strong>

I'll second that! Sparky is and always will a manchester red!</strong><hr></blockquote>

He's a united legend alright, but manager? Not as his first club role. I agree with the people who've raised questions about his credentials to manage at club level. It's a whole different ball game to international management.
You play 10 internationals a year max. The rest of the time is spent watching players etc. Domestically you pass ten games by mid september. Then there's transfers, contracts. He may be a good choice one day but not till he's got some experience of club management first