AlgerianRed
Guest
Sir Alex said 'Every TOP player wants to play for Man Utd' so that means you are not included , so are all but 2-3 players from Liverpool, with all do respect.
Originally posted by miclino:
<strong>Stats don't lie, Henchoz and Hyppia were among the top 4 defenders last year.(I didn't see any Man Utd defenders in the top 10 even)</strong><hr></blockquote>
Just curious, who were the top ten defenders and where can I find those statistics?
Originally posted by Rory Fitz:
<strong>Big words friends, but Stephane could walk into your team at the moment
I was actually gonna post a topic in here , to see if you want him or not - would you.
Ferdinand & Henchoz
Ferdinand & Blanc
Ferdinand & Neville
I know which one I would want, Hyypia and Henchman
- Seriously, he is better than the partners available at the moment for Rio</strong><hr></blockquote>
henchoz is a good solid player who does his job very well when accompanied by hyppia and the rest of the defencive players HAMMAN, GERRARD, RISE, CARRAGER/BABBLE, HESKEY etc. but to say that as an individual he is a better player than blanc is well, stupid. BLANC is a skillful, calm, intelligent player who idealy could be paired with a player like henchoz ... who although effective is simply a bruiser sombody to put in hard challeges and clear the ball by any mean possible while a player like blanc/hyppia look after the football side of defending.
Currently at UNITED we don't have a player like henchoz, all our defenders can actually play football pretty well and are highly skilled maybe this is our downfall, but if united were to sign henchoz or a player of his type i would concider it a step backwards.
Originally posted by JOBT:
<strong>
henchoz is a good solid player who does his job very well when accompanied by hyppia and the rest of the defencive players HAMMAN, GERRARD, RISE, CARRAGER/BABBLE, HESKEY etc. but to say that as an individual he is a better player than blanc is well, stupid. BLANC is a skillful, calm, intelligent player who idealy could be paired with a player like henchoz ... who although effective is simply a bruiser sombody to put in hard challeges and clear the ball by any mean possible while a player like blanc/hyppia look after the football side of defending.
Currently at UNITED we don't have a player like henchoz, all our defenders can actually play football pretty well and are highly skilled maybe this is our downfall, but if united were to sign henchoz or a player of his type i would concider it a step backwards.</strong><hr></blockquote>
Thank you for a well thought out post
Stephane may not be the elegant passer of the ball, but he wins challenges, blocks the ball and is able to head it clear. It is an advantage to have a passer of the ball in your defence.
Currently United dont have a player of the calibre of Henchoz, Blanc has improved but he is not better than Henchoz. In his prime , yes, but currently ?
United have a very shaky defence, the dogs on the street know that. You have invested £30 million in order to try and solve that problem and have offered Bblanc a 1 year extension to cover the possibility that you wouldnt get Rio.
If you didnt get Rio then Ferguson would have had a retired Blanc, Johnsen who left and that leaves an inexperienced O'Shea and lucky dip between 3 players to play out of position.
Blanc improved towards the end of the season but it is doubtful that he can play a full season again.
In my view, United are in need of a Stephane Henchoz and is currently better than what is avalable with the exception of young Oo'Shea would could develop into a class act
Originally posted by Sambora:
<strong>can somebody tell me what "foa" stands for? <img src="graemlins/lol.gif" border="0" alt="[Laugh Out Loud]" /> </strong><hr></blockquote>
F*ck Off ABU's <img src="graemlins/lol.gif" border="0" alt="[Laugh Out Loud]" />
Originally posted by Rory Fitz:
<strong>Big words friends, but Stephane could walk into your team at the moment
</strong><hr></blockquote>
Sorry but we already have two goalkeepers, thank you anyway.Also I think Blanc when Half drunk is still better than Handchoz <img src="graemlins/lol.gif" border="0" alt="[Laugh Out Loud]" />
Originally posted by miclino:
<strong>Stats don't lie, Henchoz and Hyppia were among the top 4 defenders last year.(I didn't see any Man Utd defenders in the top 10 even)</strong><hr></blockquote>
Stats don't lie. But most of the time, they mislead, if you don't know how to interprete them.
Originally posted by Rory Fitz:
<strong>Big words friends, but Stephane could walk into your team at the moment
I was actually gonna post a topic in here , to see if you want him or not - would you.
Ferdinand & Henchoz
Ferdinand & Blanc
Ferdinand & Neville
</strong><hr></blockquote>
Ferdinand & Blanc
Originally posted by Rory Fitz:
<strong>
Thank you for a well thought out post
Stephane may not be the elegant passer of the ball, but he wins challenges, blocks the ball and is able to head it clear. It is an advantage to have a passer of the ball in your defence.
Currently United dont have a player of the calibre of Henchoz, Blanc has improved but he is not better than Henchoz. In his prime , yes, but currently ?
United have a very shaky defence, the dogs on the street know that. You have invested £30 million in order to try and solve that problem and have offered Bblanc a 1 year extension to cover the possibility that you wouldnt get Rio.
If you didnt get Rio then Ferguson would have had a retired Blanc, Johnsen who left and that leaves an inexperienced O'Shea and lucky dip between 3 players to play out of position.
Blanc improved towards the end of the season but it is doubtful that he can play a full season again.
In my view, United are in need of a Stephane Henchoz and is currently better than what is avalable with the exception of young Oo'Shea would could develop into a class act</strong><hr></blockquote>
Why is it doubtful Blanc will last another full season????
Man United, with the back four of Irwin - Neville - Brown - Silvestre the mostly used, had the best defensive record in the Prem the season before last. Compare that back four with a back four of Neville - Rio - Blanc - Silvestre..