By your criterion in the MU forum...
"If you want to speculate about players United should sign, take it to the Transfer forum"
... should the sticky above yours in that forum be moved?
I'd thought that the transfer forum was about speculation and rumour about who was moving - whereas, since this forum concerns MUFC, issues concerning team performance and development including possible strengthening would be best placed here. Identifying weaknesses and suggesting fixes including possible acquisitions seemed to me to fit well here. Sort of a 'we need a player like X to do job Y' which then leads to who would fit and would we therefore be interested.
I'd be grateful if you could clarify the demarcation - should it be as your sticky describes and therefore should the other sticky be moved? Opinions from all mods invited.
"If you want to speculate about players United should sign, take it to the Transfer forum"
... should the sticky above yours in that forum be moved?
I'd thought that the transfer forum was about speculation and rumour about who was moving - whereas, since this forum concerns MUFC, issues concerning team performance and development including possible strengthening would be best placed here. Identifying weaknesses and suggesting fixes including possible acquisitions seemed to me to fit well here. Sort of a 'we need a player like X to do job Y' which then leads to who would fit and would we therefore be interested.
I'd be grateful if you could clarify the demarcation - should it be as your sticky describes and therefore should the other sticky be moved? Opinions from all mods invited.
