Criteria Draft R1 - Fenômeno vs Ralaks

With players at their peak, who would win?


  • Total voters
    13
  • Poll closed .

Enigma_87

You know who
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
28,156
Team Fenômeno
cs4qaP5.png


vs Team Ralaks
AlCNTKbl.png



Fenomeno Tactics:

How often do we see George Best shunted out on the wing in drafts? And mostly having to share the other flank with another dominant winger and no.10? Anyone who has watched Best would know he was much more than a touchline winger, he was at in his element being able to have free reign to switch wings and also operate in central areas, his highlights reel is full of goals scored all across the front line. Infact one of his most important goals of his career was receiving the ball from a flick on running from the center and then dribbling past the CB and GK to score.

Here Best is given a free role to work his magic, he has the license to roam and work both wings and attack through the center. He links up with his good mate Sir Bobby, a proven partnership that won it all, he also has Van Basten upfront to combine with, a better version of Law who he also worked so well with. In wide areas, support is provided by two excellent attacking full backs who are also able to whip in quality crosses to MvB. The midfield and defence provide a solid base, with hard working midfielders, world class defenders and goalkeeper.

I'm not entirely sure how the opposition will lineup but their main threat will be Garrincha, whilst an incredible player i think we have a really good counter with Kohler and Cabrini defending those areas. Whilst on the other hand Best will be instructed to have a go at Camacho who is the weak link when considering both defenses.

Ralaks Tactics:
Formation:
4-3-3 (false 9)

Defense:

Standard back four covered by the legendary Buffon in behind. Beckenbauer will naturally be allowed to push up with the ball and spread it as he sees fit. Two options can happen when he pushes up, either (temporarily) swapping to a back three where all three would function well, or Busquets pushing back into the defensive line to cover. Busquets was supremely intelligent in his reading of the game, so I am entrusting him to evaluate the situation moment my moment. Camacho is more bound to the defensive side, as his partner on the other side is more naturally gifted and likely would have a great partnership with Garrincha on the right wing. In either case, Busquets will have a natural role in covering the right side, if/when Beckenbauer or Amoros pushes up.

Midfield:

Sergio Busquets – one of the modern greats in his natural number 6 position, where his role is the same as it was for Barcelona & Spain during his prime. Suarez will function as the playmaking heart in midfield, whilst Seedorf will be the hardworking box-2-box midfielder. Both Busquets and Seedorf are relentless pressers and will make up for Suarez, maybe being more focused on creating. Seedorf will give a direct presence in the left half-space to supplement the more defensive Camacho and offensive Rensenbrink. Suarez will thrive in combination with Garrincha and Amoros on the right side, doing one-two passes with Garrincha & Amoros.

Attack:

Baggo employed in a false 9 with fantastic wingers on either side. He would function very well in this role, allowing him to use his reading of the game to influence it as he wants, allowing Garrincha, Rensenbrink, Seedorf & Suarez to push into the box. I have plenty of runners to be extra runners into the box when he drops deeper.
 
Thanks for setting up.

Good team by @Ralaks but i don't see the need for both Busquets and Suarez in that midfield especially with Beckenbuaer behind them (albeit with an arrow showing he will be instructed to push into midfield). It's true there are two versions of Suarez, the first being the attacking midfielder however this would clash with Baggio dropping deep and the second version was a DLP similar to Busquets, so i don't see the midfield working at full potential. Have already mentioned Best/Cabrini targeting Camacho is the way to go against that defense.
 
Thanks for setting up.

Good team by @Ralaks but i don't see the need for both Busquets and Suarez in that midfield especially with Beckenbuaer behind them (albeit with an arrow showing he will be instructed to push into midfield). It's true there are two versions of Suarez, the first being the attacking midfielder however this would clash with Baggio dropping deep and the second version was a DLP similar to Busquets, so i don't see the midfield working at full potential. Have already mentioned Best/Cabrini targeting Camacho is the way to go against that defense.

cheers, your team is fantastic and would've preferred to avoid it I think

I don't see any problem in particular with Busquets and Suarez together, not too dissimilar to classic possesion heavy Barcelona combinations, I mean Xavi functioned often as a deep lying playmaker together with Busquets being the more defensive midfielder, which is his role in this team too. Maybe it's limiting him compared to what he could also do, but he is fantastic in that role also. Camacho is probably my weakest link, but he still great and would've never survived at Real Madrid in that period without being able to fill out his role in defense. Add Seedorf tireless running and I see it as a fair game, especially with Rensenbrink also being in the back of Cabrini's mind.

I think Garrincha and Rensenbrink will enjoy facing a back three with pushed up full backs, which is where I will put my focus on winning the match, if Kohler or Santos are pulled out wide, then I have three players who are magnificent at arriving late in the box from different outsets (Seedorf, Baggio & Suarez). Casemiro and Schweinsteiger will have to be busy covering their runs for sure.

My creativity will be difficult to contain, it's not like block out Suarez and then I'm inhibited, (Beckenbauer, Busquets & Baggio dropping deep), wheras I feel your team might be struggling a bit in that sense, both of your deeper midfielders are not particularly creative forces (not saying they can't pass of course, but they are not proper playmakers), so if I manage to contain your creativity away from Charlton and Best, then your gameplan is severely hindered (not easy, but a viable game plan, imo)

Good luck!
 
love fenomeno side, specially the use of best that really is refreshing.

ralaks has weird combination of possession Gods and the complete opposite
 
Best in a free role is the real difference maker here, and I'm very happy to see him be used in this manner rather than as a conventional winger.
 
cheers, your team is fantastic and would've preferred to avoid it I think

I don't see any problem in particular with Busquets and Suarez together, not too dissimilar to classic possesion heavy Barcelona combinations, I mean Xavi functioned often as a deep lying playmaker together with Busquets being the more defensive midfielder, which is his role in this team too. Maybe it's limiting him compared to what he could also do, but he is fantastic in that role also. Camacho is probably my weakest link, but he still great and would've never survived at Real Madrid in that period without being able to fill out his role in defense. Add Seedorf tireless running and I see it as a fair game, especially with Rensenbrink also being in the back of Cabrini's mind.

I think Garrincha and Rensenbrink will enjoy facing a back three with pushed up full backs, which is where I will put my focus on winning the match, if Kohler or Santos are pulled out wide, then I have three players who are magnificent at arriving late in the box from different outsets (Seedorf, Baggio & Suarez). Casemiro and Schweinsteiger will have to be busy covering their runs for sure.

My creativity will be difficult to contain, it's not like block out Suarez and then I'm inhibited, (Beckenbauer, Busquets & Baggio dropping deep), wheras I feel your team might be struggling a bit in that sense, both of your deeper midfielders are not particularly creative forces (not saying they can't pass of course, but they are not proper playmakers), so if I manage to contain your creativity away from Charlton and Best, then your gameplan is severely hindered (not easy, but a viable game plan, imo)

Good luck!
Thanks! I think Xavi was a different type of midfielder, more of a metronome where you can give him the ball, recycle it and not worry about losing it, he was less of a DLP which both Busquets and Suarez are. Don't have much issue with your frontline it's quite complementary in isolation, however i do feel they are the antithesis of the type of football Busquets and Suarez like to play, in that they were more direct ball players rather than possession based/off the ball runners . Particularly Garrincha who was more of a traditional ball carrying winger rather than wing forward.

With regards to my midfield two, i think you are underrating their ball playing ability, Casemiro didn't really get to show this off too much at Madrid because it was mostly delegated to Modric and Kroos however he's pretty good on the ball as he's shown at United (shame his legs have failed). Bastian is pretty versatile and was doing the playmaking when partnered with Javi Martinez at Bayern and Khedira for Germany. Not to forget Sir Bobby was really involved and his incredible work rate allowed him to be involved in deeper areas too.

I think we are fine with you retaining the ball allowing us to hit on the counter which makes it less likely that our defense will get caught out, it's not just the back three but both Cabrini and Maicon were really hard working and will put a shift in to get back, and as touched on above Sir Bobby would also help out in midfield- it was just the type of midfielder he was.