Beckham of England Vs Beckham of United

TOD

Guest
Well... David Beckham had done it again, putting 110% effort for England but hardly 50% for United. Whats wrong with him? Or did UNITED failed to fully utilized his abilities? From what i had watch from yesterday, i see a different Beckham from that of UNITED's Beckham. What are your views on this?
 
I didn't really see England's match so I won't talk tactics.

But anyone who says Beckham doesn't give his all to United is nuts.
 
Originally posted by TOD:
<strong>Well... David Beckham had done it again, putting 110% effort for England but hardly 50% for United. Whats wrong with him? Or did UNITED failed to fully utilized his abilities? From what i had watch from yesterday, i see a different Beckham from that of UNITED's Beckham. What are your views on this?</strong><hr></blockquote>

He gives his all. Beckham was voted man of the match for us against Everton.
 
I don't think that it is that Beckham plays any more or less for United and England, it's just that he is asked to be a different player. For England, he has to be THE man. They need him to be. While for United he is an integral part but with the players in the squad he doesnt always have to be superman. To me, besides Keano, he shows the most passion in the squad during games.
 
Originally posted by epgino159:
I don't think that it is that Beckham plays any more or less for United and England, it's just that he is asked to be a different player. For England, he has to be THE man. They need him to be. While for United he is an integral part but with the players in the squad he doesnt always have to be superman. To me, besides Keano, he shows the most passion in the squad during games.
<hr></blockquote>

I agree -- I think he plays as well for United as he does for England, however when he does play for England, criticism is always less from the so-called neutrals and there is a camera on him showing what he does right!

So he looks better - also he doesn't play for England week in week out ...
 
ouch ...those tackles ...is there a more petulant aspect coming into is game , or is the word committment...either way he was lucky to stay on the pitch Sat
 
I was just saying that he was not as influenzial for UNITED compared to England. When was the last time he got us a draw or a win single-handedly? And i must also add that Veron had the same problem too, but we can say Veron's not suited to the English game, but Beckham??? <img src="confused.gif" border="0">
 
Originally posted by TOD:
<strong>I was just saying that he was not as influenzial for UNITED compared to England. When was the last time he got us a draw or a win single-handedly? And i must also add that Veron had the same problem too, but we can say Veron's not suited to the English game, but Beckham??? :confused: </strong><hr></blockquote>

Veron doesn't have the same problem as you think. Veron doesn't play well for Argentina either. i believe he was among the players that caused argentina to flop in the WC.

Like i said TOD, becks was voted man of the match for us against everton. we can't blame the man for being man-marked because he's good.

Has anyone notice that our oppositions have been giving us less free kicks on the edge of the penalty box lately? I think becks won't get too many freekicks this year. it's sad.
 
anyway, class players will always be class players.

I believe strongly that both becks and veron will find their touches and take us to glory!! :cool:
 
Seems to me Becks has different roles playing for England and MU. For England he is The Man, the Maradona, with instructions to lead from the front and make it happen. For MU he is a right half who is only too happy to point out the Roy Kean is the club captain. Other guys like Giggs, Scholes, RVN are there to work the miracles, Becks is there to help them happen. The man's discipline and professionalism have been fantastic even on the days things haven't worked for him.
 
ive also notice he had not been putting in the crosses lately, he looks to me that he tries to be an all-rounded player, which he isn't not. Beckham is a special player, mainly because of his crossing, and if he does'nt do what he does best, he will be like any other player in the pitch, as simple as that. Look at the way Becks perform during the TREBLE season, firing crosses from the right all the time, no dribbling, no dilly dally keep ball, no looking for foul near the box, just simple one time cross, and it usually ends up with a goal.
 
Originally posted by Rod:
<strong>Seems to me Becks has different roles playing for England and MU. For England he is The Man, the Maradona, with instructions to lead from the front and make it happen. For MU he is a right half who is only too happy to point out the Roy Kean is the club captain. Other guys like Giggs, Scholes, RVN are there to work the miracles, Becks is there to help them happen. The man's discipline and professionalism have been fantastic even on the days things haven't worked for him.</strong><hr></blockquote>

My opinion is the same as you. Beckham in England is the playmaker and the centre of everything. I can even predict that Sven ask his players to try to find their captain and pass the ball to him whenever possible. However,
Beckham in United is just a part of a big star-pecked midfield. Veron, Keano, Giggs, etc., all can make thing happen themselves without going thru Beckham. Therefore to compare the influence of Becks in England and in United is a wrong thing from the start, IMO.
 
Originally posted by uranushk1:
<strong>

My opinion is the same as you. Beckham in England is the playmaker and the centre of everything. I can even predict that Sven ask his players to try to find their captain and pass the ball to him whenever possible. However,
Beckham in United is just a part of a big star-pecked midfield. Veron, Keano, Giggs, etc., all can make thing happen themselves without going thru Beckham. Therefore to compare the influence of Becks in England and in United is a wrong thing from the start, IMO.</strong><hr></blockquote>

but don't you see that we expect a lot from our players in all positions? You can't say that just because we have a star-studded team certain players don't need to play their hearts out in crunch times.

Beckham still gets a lot of ball during the United games, but I am one of those who feel he's not doing what he's best at. Beckham keeps trying new things. Maybe it's good individually for his own improvement in the game, but it could end up hurting us in terms of scoreline.

I believe he's still giving 100% to all the matches we play, but he's also not willing to finish his career as simply the passer of the ball. He wants to do other things... become as influencial as Zidane, Rivaldo and maybe Cryuff... he wants to be a more complete player... can't blame him, but still can't feel like he's benefitting the team at the moment. Maybe in a bit of time when he's really improved in the area he feels he needs work in.
 
Originally posted by RUnited:
<strong>

but don't you see that we expect a lot from our players in all positions? You can't say that just because we have a star-studded team certain players don't need to play their hearts out in crunch times.

Beckham still gets a lot of ball during the United games, but I am one of those who feel he's not doing what he's best at. Beckham keeps trying new things. Maybe it's good individually for his own improvement in the game, but it could end up hurting us in terms of scoreline.

I believe he's still giving 100% to all the matches we play, but he's also not willing to finish his career as simply the passer of the ball. He wants to do other things... become Zidane of England, Rivaldo of Brazil and maybe Cryuff of Holland... he wants to be a more complete player... can't blame him, but still can't feel like he's benefitting the team at the moment. Maybe in a bit of time when he's really improved in the area he feels he needs work in.</strong><hr></blockquote>


I don't think Beckham changes his game without the approvement/guiding of Fergie and the coaches. May be Fergie think that with Beckham's talent and vision he should be more than just a crossing matchine from the right. For the first thing, I can already see Beckham scored more goals last season. Let's be a bit more patient and see if Beckham's change of his game can finally benefit us in the long run.
 
I agree with you on that Beckham is not as influencial when playing for United, but Beckham still gets a lot of ball during the United games. I am one of those who feel he's not doing what he's best at. He keeps trying new things. Maybe it's good individually for his own improvement in the game, but it could end up hurting us in terms of scoreline.

I believe he's still giving 100% to all the matches we play, but he's also not willing to finish his career as simply the passer of the ball. He wants to do other things... become as influencial as Zidane, Rivaldo and maybe Cryuff... he wants to be a more complete player... can't blame him, but still can't feel like he's benefitting the team at the moment. Maybe his improved skills will help us in a bit of time when he's really improved in the area he feels he needs work in.
 
The same critisism is often labelled at Owen, as it looks like he is putting more in for England and less for Liverpool. I don't know why this is, obviously all players should and i assume would put in 100% for whichever team the play for.
 
Beckham for England reminds me of Keano, the same determination, never say die, and a bit of the devil about him.
 
Shame he doesn't show it for United, looking at his performances for the two, u would think England were paying him 100k a week to play and playing for free at United.
 
Originally posted by FlyingPasty:
<strong>Shame he doesn't show it for United, looking at his performances for the two, u would think England were paying him 100k a week to play and playing for free at United.</strong><hr></blockquote>
He was struggling for fitness at the start of the season, but his performances have been improving in the last few matches.
 
Originally posted by FlyingPasty:
<strong>Shame he doesn't show it for United, looking at his performances for the two, u would think England were paying him 100k a week to play and playing for free at United.</strong><hr></blockquote>

Nevertheless, he was named Man of the Match in the Everton game. That proves he's still got the thirst to win for us.

He maybe discouraged by the fact that the oppositions have all decided to take him down. From not letting him play easily on the right wing to not giving away too many free kicks in front of their boxes.
 
OK...lets not argue about this anymore, the best way to prove it is in the stats, is there any statistians out or anybody knows how many assist has he made for England and for UNITED in the past 2 years? <img src="confused.gif" border="0">
 
Dont think England have played as much as united over the last 2 years!! :D
 
I think he does lift his game for England. He certainly seems more up for it anyway.
 
Originally posted by TOD:
<strong>OK...lets not argue about this anymore, the best way to prove it is in the stats, is there any statistians out or anybody knows how many assist has he made for England and for UNITED in the past 2 years? :confused: </strong><hr></blockquote>

football isn't about stats.