Seems like a good player - can dribble, tackle, wins duels - and fairly young. Tenacious and was a handful in our match at Goodison. Haven’t seen much of him, but what’s the Caf’s opinion on his ceiling?
Amadou Onana | Villa watch
- Thread starter Suedesi
- Start date
-
Hello, Guest! We have four new competitions (with taglines and awards as prizes) starting.
A new Odds or Evens competition is starting now. Click here to read the rules and message Damien to submit your eight players by 14th September 2024
A new Carabao Cup prediction competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for round 3 which begins 17th September.
A new Champions League prediction competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for the first round which begins 17th September.
A new Europa League prediction competition is starting now. Click here to enter to submit predictions for the first round which begins 25th September.
For Odds or Evens you have until the 14th September to submit your players. Submissions will be open for the next 7 days, 13 hours, 1 minute, 38 seconds, and will close on Sep 14, 2024 at 12:30. -
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) and Jamie (@Vault Dweller) get the depressing job of reviewing United's 3-0 loss at Old Trafford to Liverpool. They discuss what went wrong, Casemiro's day to forget, and the pressure now on Erik Ten Hag. They also take some time to give McTominay a proper farewell, and give their overall thoughts on the Summer Transfer Window.
I thought he looked quite clumsy against us.
He’s unit alright and he can play at a good level but not sure he is good enough for a big club.
His technique seems poor but he's very mobile for someone that size. Combined with an engine and he's a handful to play against.
Better at winning the ball and causing mayhem thanks to his physique than at passing it around
Everton seemed to be very excited when signing him but I'm yet to work out what his strengths are. Just seems a decent footballer with a massive frame to me. I'm sure he'll keep developing though.
Everton’s new Fellaini. Not meant in a disparaging way, Fellaini was one of their best midfielders when he played for them and a real handful.
Moyes missed out bigtime he's definitely his type
Everton really do like their lumbering midfield oaf. Fellaini, Doucore and this Onana lad.
Not the type of midfielder we should be looking at though, not good enough on the ball for a team that should ideally have more of the it than 70-80% of teams they face.
Not the type of midfielder we should be looking at though, not good enough on the ball for a team that should ideally have more of the it than 70-80% of teams they face.
I like him in Everton's midfield - seems to play well against us yet again
Cushy player.
When he's been on his feet, he's been okay.
I’m thinking this guy wouldn’t be a bad pick up for relatively cheap if Everton gets relegated
Agree. If Caicedo becomes unattainable due to the price Onana looks a very good option. Has settled into the league quite well
Poor on the ball. Not available often enough, gives it away too much, no passing range. Pretty dire combination for a player at a top side.
Yeah he's not very press resistant, his touch is too loose. And he tries to compensate by dribbling out of these areas, but gets caught too often. I think he'll get better and maybe in a year or two, he'll be a good option for a top team but he needs to improve some basics first.
Actually his long passing technique is pretty good and he is getting a lot better in recent games I've watched. Yesterday for instance I thought he was brilliant.
He is primarily a ball winner but he is adjusting to the pace of the league where he is getting caught out still at times. I think as a cheap backup to Case he is a good shout if Everton do go down. Him and Lavia are ones to keep an eye on
For me it doesn't add up, he's still fairly young and if he's adjusting as you say then both of those things mean he needs regular football at a club more befitting of his current level. I don't think he adds anything to us right now, he hardly impacts the game in possession so I think he's on the bench most of the time. Most of the time we need to break down worse sides so a DM needs more than athleticism and breaking up play and if you look at Everton they can't progress the ball for toffee which he's a part of...
McTominay is probably as good if not better, he's just not very fashionable but I'm pretty sure he could go to this Everton side and stand out and we'd be saying the same thing. McTominay could be a good squad option!
Excellent today, much more than just a run around destroyer
He's better than Mctominay for me. Mctominay is also 26 whereas Onana is 21
Lampards parting gift.
I love this guy, an absolute monster. Reminds me Patrick Viera so much, massive presence, extremely comfortable on the ball, tackles everything that moves, never stops moving and seems to have an absolutely fantastic attitude. Moshiri the lunatic would surely take a straight swap if we offered McTom
Maupay has to be Darth Vader reincarnated 
Well yeah, of course I'd have him swapped for McTominay in an instant for that reason.
Still don't think he's top club material.
Love him he is an absolute unit
That run where he crossed the ball across Arsenal's box... Shows you he is more than a destroyer.
Looks a prospect.
Chelsea were linked weren't they.....
Chelsea were linked weren't they.....
Another strong performance. He has been getting better a lot as the season has progressed
Not the most graceful by any means, but will compete for the ball and has some pace and ability to run the ball and hes huge
He's class.
Hope we stay up as if we do someone will pay a silly 80m on him.
Was that where Calvert-Lewin just needed to get a better connection,would definitely take him in our midfield no doubt
His dribbling gets lost very easily.
Will show like a sore thumb at United but good for a club like Everton
Will show like a sore thumb at United but good for a club like Everton
He'll be the next Fellaini at Everton (and Fellaini at United if we sign him). A very physical player though.
There's a cluster of clubs looking for midfielders in the summer, with Rice and Caceido near the top of most lists. I think Onana will be the next option for those clubs that fail to land either.
Sold in the summer.
Hes only 19 so plenty of time for him to develop. As for his ceiling, remains to be seen. A season under dyche will improve him.
He is 21, but same point applies
They look perfectly suited as a pair, I fancy Belgium to still be pretty good in like 6 years when they have far less talent but less egos and an size and speed pairing of De Kaetelare-Openda in front of them. Looks made for being an annoying QF team.
Good to hear, although I'm sure Caceido said the same a few days before his statement saying he wishes to go.