All-Time team built around Arrigo Sacchi's tactics

Invictus

Poster of the Year 2015 & 2018
Staff
Joined
Mar 22, 2014
Messages
15,417
Supports
Piracy on the High Seas.
Since we've addressed close to a dozen GOAT footballers, perhaps it's time to move on to the elite managers in a build around theme? Posters have the option of selecting from an unrestricted pool — including players that were managed by Sacchi, obviously.

Overview of team/player characteristics — which will serve as the guiding principles for the XI:

Proactive compactness from back to front to asphyxiate the opposition — ultraoffensivo high press by the attackers backed up by a high defensive line to trap and press them in their own half as a block — moving on to the zonal era in Italian football, in contrast with reactiveness and traditional sweeper + man-marker + creator-in-chief #10 approach.

Players have to be incredibly fit and versed in a collective method considering the scheme was very demanding and organized — like the Italian version of totaalvoetbal, but also mentally sharp to digest Sacchi's guidelines and perceptive to make a million synchronized positional adjustments in-game and focused to keep the intensity going week-in and week-out.

Subtle changes in formation don't matter that much as long as Sacchi's actual principles are at the forefront — not dogmatically of course, they had freedom to express themselves...switching from 4-4-2 to 4-2-4 or narrow diamond, but closely-knit banks of 4s in defense and midfield with a swashbuckling forward leading the charge (Gullit) and a technically capable #9 holding a high line and acting as the fulcrum (Van Basten) is the most iconic setup.

Attempt #1 based on a tried and tested Milanese recipe:

X.png


  • Upgraded defense — quite possibly the sturdiest Back-5 possible with the addition of Djalma, Nesta and Buffon.
  • Slightly reconfigured midfield dynamics with Suárez representing an incredible upgrade over Ancelotti. Nedvěd and Figo has good workrate for their position.
  • Gullit was rampant at his peak — one of the cornerstones of Milan under Sacchi, the spark of inspiration that brought everything together as the natural on-field leader, and proven with Van Basten — so substituting him seems a bit draft. But O Rei was an irresistible option and should fit right in as a talisman, IMO.
 
I don't know about Djalma there. Tassotti did venture forward from time to time. Prefer someone more balanced there, perhaps Zanetti.

Also, might as well call it an Alex Ferguson lineup. The similarity is uncanny.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Invictus
Figo really better than Gullit? Imo Baresi, Rijkaard, Gullit and MVB should be the automatic choices in this team.
 
Figo really better than Gullit? Imo Baresi, Rijkaard, Gullit and MVB should be the automatic choices in this team.
If you put Gullit here, you put him up front instead of Pelé, not on the right.
 
Gullit on the right doesn't matter, he will pop up everywhere regardless to combine with Johann:drool:

zyakar.png


Not entirely true to the dogmatic principles of Sacchi, but the main objective was a different one for me anyway: build a better side than Invictus' without any of his players while building a side somewhat in the mould of Sacchi style:) At least I have a proper sweeper keeper to go with the high line:p
 
Last edited:
building a side somewhat in the mould of Sacchi style:) At least I have a proper sweeper keeper to go with the high line:p
Sarri’s Milan was famous for not needing a keeper at all though, so you’re both are stepping away from the philosophy :) Karius will do.

Not a fan of Redondo if we’re talking about him in Sacchi’s system.
 
Sarri’s Milan was famous for not needing a keeper at all though, so you’re both are stepping away from the philosophy :) Karius will do.

Not a fan of Redondo if we’re talking about him in Sacchi’s system.

Ah that reminds me of the way some people talk about Maldini and Baresi, the way they are praised sometimes you would think their sides never conceded a goal with them on the pitch:lol: In all seriousness, I think Neuer is the best Sacchi keeper.

What is wrong with Redondo?
 
Sarri’s Milan was famous for not needing a keeper at all though, so you’re both are stepping away from the philosophy :) Karius will do.

Not a fan of Redondo if we’re talking about him in Sacchi’s system.

Why? He had Ancelotti who is a lot similar to Rendondo, albeit the latter pretty much better in every department.
 
What is wrong with Redondo?

Why? He had Ancelotti who is a lot similar to Rendondo, albeit the latter pretty much better in every department.

I feel that Redondo prefers a different tempo — he was a master of slowing the game down and generally loved to spend more time with the ball instead of quickly releasing it. That’s why he was so beautiful to watch. I’m not saying that he wasn’t capable of changing the tempo — the most iconic moment of his career came from a bursting run forward, but he preferred a more composed approach. Again, this is not a criticism of him — there’s more than one way to skin a cat, but he wouldn’t be my choice for Sacchi’s team.
 
I don't know about Djalma there. Tassotti did venture forward from time to time. Prefer someone more balanced there, perhaps Zanetti.
Nothing against Zanetti, but Djalma was more complete than he's portrayed in Café drafts, so this comment is quite intriguing. Not going to sit here and pretend he could match someone like Alves in terms of offensive output or Cafú in terms of tireless running ability, but in a Sacchi team where the fullbacks were measured and calculating, he's a shoe-in. The narrative around Djalma as a pure cover defender is a bit flawed because he had to be reserved to make up for Garrincha's eccentricity — an interpretation that was very much born out necessity and didn't carry over to Palmeiras or Portuguesa, and in some ways Djalma helped pioneer attacking play for fullbacks — though it was obviously taken to higher levels by subsequent generations. Tassotti was even nicknamed “Djalma Santos” to highlight his complete and consistent style, and timing on the overlap...so consider it an homage rather than a strict fit-based upgrade, if you will.
Tassotti was a defensive minded fullback, who was known for his strength, anticipation, defensive awareness, marking ability, and tactical intelligence, which allowed him to excel in Milan's zonal marking system. While at Lazio, he earned a reputation for being a tenacious, hard tackling, and aggressive player; at Milan, he developed into a more cautious, composed, and consistent player, which led to him being nicknamed "the professor".
Although he primarily excelled defensively, Tassotti was a modern and versatile full-back, who also capable of being an attacking threat on the wing, due to his pace, stamina, ball distribution, and technical ability, which he was able to improve extensively under the tutelage of Nils Liedholm; this later led his team mates to give him the nickname the new "Djalma Santos".
http://www.acmilan-forum.com/viewtopic.php?t=83
Figo really better than Gullit? Imo Baresi, Rijkaard, Gullit and MVB should be the automatic choices in this team.
Nope, Figo and Nedvěd start over Donadoni/Columbo/Evani — Pelé starts over Gullit. You know I'm a massive Gullit fan and he certainly has a lot going in his favor in Sacchi lineup no less, but Pelé epitomized tour-de-force forward play in similar-ish positions and reeled me in with the gravitational pull of a SMBH. :lol:

Baresi, Maldini, Rijkaard are slightly different cases because they're pretty much un-upgradable — and Van Basten is on a comparable plane to Müller/Fenômeno, albeit unmatched in a Sacchi team and the best at providing verticality or holding a high line against resolute defenses in peak Serie A as the lynchpin of attack.
 
Wrt. Ancelotti, I was kinda torn between Suárez and this gentleman in throwback roles:



Think both had the organisational ability, tactical nous, understanding of team-work, and blended artistic vision with grit to excel in a Sacchi team as upgrades over Carlo.
 
Inclined to keep the Van Basten/Gullit partnership. Both for synergy and for pressing from the front capabilities. After all a Sacchi system is founded on its collective graft and I'm not sold on Pele fully subscribing to his off the ball duties.

@Invictus Agree with your Bozsik call there, came to mind as I thought of top end Ancelotti upgrades.

Van Basten - Gullit
Nedved - Rijkaard - Schweinsteiger - Figo
Maldini - Baresi - Kohler - Djalma
Buffon​

Perhaps more challenging to do it without any Sacchi players, such was the quality of his Milan side that 3-4 of them are certainties.
 
Schweinsteiger
Excellent choice given his complete skill set and industry. Fantastic in a pivot alongside Martínez under Heynckes, too. Funnily enough, I considered Ribéry for the left midfielder position, but totally forgot about Fußballgott! :lol:
 
Nothing against Zanetti, but Djalma was more complete than he's portrayed in Café drafts, so this comment is quite intriguing. Not going to sit here and pretend he could match someone like Alves in terms of offensive output or Cafú in terms of tireless running ability, but in a Sacchi team where the fullbacks were measured and calculating, he's a shoe-in. The narrative around Djalma as a pure cover defender is a bit flawed because he had to be reserved to make up for Garrincha's eccentricity — an interpretation that was very much born out necessity and didn't carry over to Palmeiras or Portuguesa, and in some ways Djalma helped pioneer attacking play for fullbacks — though it was obviously taken to higher levels by subsequent generations. Tassotti was even nicknamed New Djalma Santos to highlight his complete and consistent style, and timing on the overlap...so consider it an homage rather than a strict fit-based upgrade, if you will.

Yeah, fair point.
 
Schweinsteiger for Ancelotti is a good match. Donadoni's a work horse and very good in defending, of which I don't see Figo could match that. I'm incline to have Beckham for that RW.
 
How about the older CRonaldo for Gullit place? Excellent header, strong, fast, skillful, and thrive as second striker.

1724086_Euro_2016_Team.jpg
 
Last edited:
How about the older CRonaldo for Gullit place? Excellent header, strong, fast, skillful, and thrive as second striker.

1724086_Euro_2016_Team.jpg

Ronaldo fits the bill nicely in terms of replicating Gullit's athleticism in and around the penalty area but he falls short when it comes to the defensive work, hard pressing and midfield contribution that Gullit provided. Gullit wasn't really the primary goalscorer for Milan either, which probably wouldn't sit well with Ronaldo. Rooney on the other hand seems like a good fit for a Sacchi team as second striker, or else I guess Ronaldo at CF in van Basten's role with a more selfless, hard-running foil at second striker could work.
 
1st season
1-8.jpg



2nd season
2-4.jpg


Staying compact was a must both vertically and horizontally.


chrontac_sacchi2.jpg
 
TACTICAL TALE

https://footballbh.net/2017/08/15/tactical-tale-arrigo-sacchi/

The highlight of their season was the 5-0 demolition of Real Madrid. Steaua Bucharest offered little resistance in the finals as they were brushed off 4-0 with respective braces from Gullit and van Basten. The morning after we beat Steaua Bucharest I woke up with a feeling I had never experienced before. It was the one which I have never experienced since. I had this unusual, sweet taste in my mouth. I realised it was the apotheosis of my life’s work”, said the Italian.


AC-Milan-Sacchi.jpg



http://www.thehardtackle.com/2012/c...-madrid-baresi-gullit-stun-spanish-champions/
 
Ronaldo fits the bill nicely in terms of replicating Gullit's athleticism in and around the penalty area but he falls short when it comes to the defensive work, hard pressing and midfield contribution that Gullit provided. Gullit wasn't really the primary goalscorer for Milan either, which probably wouldn't sit well with Ronaldo. Rooney on the other hand seems like a good fit for a Sacchi team as second striker, or else I guess Ronaldo at CF in van Basten's role with a more selfless, hard-running foil at second striker could work.

Yeh, I was looking for the output style. Agreed that CRonaldo doesn't have that defensive work grit and willing to be the foil role. I get your point about Rooney. It's just hard to see Rooney match the physicality of Gullit. Maybe Sir Bobby? hehehehe..
 
Not using any of Sacchi's coached players.

--------------------Müller------------------
-----------------Di Stefano----------------
Nedvěd-----Davids-----Bozsik-------Figo
Facchetti----Scirea-----Kohler----Thuram
--------------------Neuer------------------
 
Neuer, Cafu, Baresi, Nesta, Maldini, Beckenbauer, Rijkaard, Zidane, Maradona, Ronaldo, Pelé