Erik ten Hag - Manchester United manager

tjb

Full Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2013
Messages
3,394
I still maintain that he deserves to at least see out his final year due to winning two trophies and having had to steward the team through the partial takeover while having to make do in several positions with loan players and a massive injury list.

Only in the palace game did I think the players weren’t really playing for him. He’s got a decent record against Liverpool other than the 7-0 and he’s beaten, Chelsea, spurs, villa and city and Arsenal in his two seasons.

I think the vast majority of the players like and respect him and I want to see if he can take us forward under the new structure. Even if it doesn’t end up working it buys time to get the new football people bedded in with a guy who we know can manage the team to a reasonable level.
What irks me is the word "deserve". He doesn't deserve anything. If we provide him the chance to have another season, he would not have earnt it. It would be us simply giving him another opportunity. The performances and results he produced last season were not good enough and as a club, we should not feel obligated to a manager. It's either we believe he can take us forward or we don't believe he can take us forward. We shouldn't be wasting seasons on semantics.
 

SoCross

Full Member
Joined
Feb 11, 2014
Messages
3,621
They need to stop dithering and say it then, maybe can finally switch focus to transfers
A “review” of the footballing season surely can’t take this long.

It is probably the opposite. If the manager was staying they would have come out by now and backed him, the fact that they haven't probably means he is gone.
Hmm. But by not making the announcement, we are hurting our preparations for next season. Shooting ourselves in the foot.

Would be typical of how we’ve gone about a few things in recent history though so maybe you’re right!

Why? Isn't the point of this new structure to enable smoother transitions between managers, rather than buying players specifically for the current manager
The point certainly is that but from a prospective players’ perspective, there would be hesitancy in joining a club without not knowing who the manager is. After all, the manager is the one who picks the team sheet.
 

Stig

Full Member
Joined
Feb 26, 2019
Messages
1,689
Depends what you want to show really.... frankly I think stats are the worst thing about football, I use my eyes and I know what I see, and I know ETH is shite
YES ! But the stats were saying something different until people pointed out that they are fake. :)
 

Stig

Full Member
Joined
Feb 26, 2019
Messages
1,689
It's really not though. Here's why:

Arteta and Klopp showed progress and you could see their fingerprint on their teams performances on the pitch.
With ETH it's the opposite.

Here's the hard stats for Klopp, Arteta and ETH for their first seasons in the PL (For Klopp and Arteta I've added their first seasons and their first 2 full seasons dsince they both started mid season):

Klopp:
1st season (started 8/10 2015 - 30 games in the PL)
1,60 points per game (under performance by 0,1 points per game)
+ 0,5 goal difference per game (over performance by 0,03 gd/game)

2nd season (Full season)
2,0 points per game (over performance by 0,14 points per game)
+ 0,95 goal difference per game (over performance by 0,34 gd/game)

3rd season
1,95 points per game (under performance by 0,12 points per game)
+ 1,21 goal difference per game (over performance by 0,42 gd/game)

Arteta:
1st season (Started 22/12 2019 - 20 games in the PL)
1,65 points per game (over performance by 0,33 points per game)
+ 0,55 goal difference per game (over performance by 0,75 gd/game)

2nd season
1,61 points per game (over performance by 0,23 points per game)
+ 0,42 goal difference per game (over performance by 0,18 gd/game)

3rd season
1,81 points per game (over performance by 0,33 points per game)
+ 0,34 goal difference per game (under performance by 0,05 gd/game)

ETH:
1st season
1,97 points per game (over performance by 0,19 points per game)
+ 0,39 goal difference per game (under performance by 0,18 gd/game)

2nd season
1,58 points per game (under performance by 0,41 points per game)
- 0,03 goal difference per game (over performance by 0,35 gd/game)

So you see progress with the first two and the opposite with ETH.

It gets even more interesting when we do the same with the underlying stats instead (from understat.com). In fact it gets really ugly:

Klopp (notice the almost linear improvement from season to season) :
1st season (started 8/10 2015 - 30 games in the PL)
1,70 expected points per game
+ 0,47 expected goal difference per game

2nd season
1,84 expected points per game
+ 0,61 expected goal difference per game

3rd season
2,09 expected points per game
+ 0,79 expected goal difference per game

Arteta (notice the almoxt linear improvement from season to season)
1st season (Started 22/12 2019 - 20 games in the PL)
1,32 expected points per game
- 0,20 expected goal difference per game

2nd season
1,55 expected points per game
+ 0,24 expected goal difference per game

3rd season
1,70 expected points per game
+ 0,39 expected goal difference per game

And then we have ETH - Notice the almost vertical drop from the first season to the second season:
1st season
1,74 expected points per game
+ 0,57 expected goal difference per game

2nd season
1,17 expected points per game
- 0,38 expected goal difference per game

The numbers in that post is meaningless because they don't show the trajectories the 3 managers had in their starting years at the respective clubs.
A graphical presentation of the results and play would be something like this:
Klopp: /
Arteta: /
ETH: \

It should be a stick to beat ETH with if anything. A big one.
Do you still want to find out where ETH's taking us next season?
But but but injuries and his stubbornness and quite a bit of stupidity haven't helped. If all those could be improved, who knows ?

But, yea, that doesn't look great. Maybe it was just a blip ?
 

Stig

Full Member
Joined
Feb 26, 2019
Messages
1,689
The longer this takes the more I want to keep him. Well played United owners.
:lol:
I feel the same, which is mad. These two dam cups keep telling me he could be ok. When I know he's a complete burke.
 

Sunny Jim

Full Member
Joined
May 8, 2007
Messages
29,505
Location
Warsaw...that's too far away from Edinburgh...
But but but injuries and his stubbornness and quite a bit of stupidity haven't helped. If all those could be improved, who knows ?

But, yea, that doesn't look great. Maybe it was just a blip ?
Sorry mate, but this is a stupid post. Yes, ETH was stubborn beyond reason at times, but injuries were a genuine problem. If you cannot understand that playing in a certain way requires certain players then I’m sorry for you.
 

spwd

likes: servals, breasts, rylan clark and zooey
Joined
Aug 11, 2010
Messages
8,965
Location
Lyecestershyre
Just checked, he has played them 5 times and won twice (Making it a 40% win rate) - No idea where the 4 comes from unless it's amount of games we played them in the league or scored vs them in the league?
Ignore it it's not correct.
 

hobbers

Full Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2013
Messages
30,298
New contract to tide him over then more money to pay when we sack him for Southgate at Christmas.

Brexit structure review fc
 

GaryLifo

Liverpool's Secret Weapon.
Joined
Feb 26, 2001
Messages
10,892
Location
From here to there
Will all those who want him gone be prepared to get behind him and the team if he is kept on?

If he got 3rd and won the europa league next season would that be considered a big step back in the right direction?
 

spwd

likes: servals, breasts, rylan clark and zooey
Joined
Aug 11, 2010
Messages
8,965
Location
Lyecestershyre
Those defending Ten Hag all season have insisted all a manager needs to succeed, is a good structure and time (because they'll definitely become Fergie or Arteta)

Therefore why would you be so against Southgate? He'll have the structure, all we need to do is give him time. What's the problem?
Exactly!
 

stevoc

Full Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2011
Messages
21,536
Will all those who want him gone be prepared to get behind him and the team if he is kept on?

If he got 3rd and won the europa league next season would that be considered a big step back in the right direction?
Yes, of course you go into the season hoping for the best.

Depends where we finish in the league. We could win the EL but finish 7th-10th. Would that make you think we're going in the right direction?
 

JPRouve

can't stop thinking about balls - NOT deflategate
Scout
Joined
Jan 31, 2014
Messages
66,973
Location
France
Will all those who want him gone be prepared to get behind him and the team if he is kept on?

If he got 3rd and won the europa league next season would that be considered a big step back in the right direction?
Why not? The vast majority of people support the club not a manager, so regardless of who is managing the team they will be behind the club and hope that everything goes as well as possible.
 

spwd

likes: servals, breasts, rylan clark and zooey
Joined
Aug 11, 2010
Messages
8,965
Location
Lyecestershyre
Maybe ineos are spreading these Southgate rumours to find the leak in the camp?
 

Redfrog

Full Member
Joined
Jun 22, 2020
Messages
2,936
There’s another reason why this could be getting delayed… he’s the manager of England. We best not be waiting for him. That would be an absolutely awful decision.
Well, if he is appointed, I will have absolutely no faith in any Ineos decisions.
 

lex talionis

Full Member
Joined
Jul 25, 2017
Messages
14,762
It does seem increasingly likely that INEOS will keep ETH and then sack him in mid-season for Southgate, once Southgate has take all the time off he needs after the Euros are done with.
 

hobbers

Full Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2013
Messages
30,298
Will all those who want him gone be prepared to get behind him and the team if he is kept on?

If he got 3rd and won the europa league next season would that be considered a big step back in the right direction?
Wont make a jot of difference if people 'get behind him' or not. The outcome will be the same, managed by Southgate by this time next year at the very latest.
 

pocco

loco
Joined
Mar 17, 2010
Messages
23,135
Location
Keep a clean shit tomorrow, United is my final bus
Will all those who want him gone be prepared to get behind him and the team if he is kept on?

If he got 3rd and won the europa league next season would that be considered a big step back in the right direction?
It's all about the football for me. Even if we won nothing next year, I'd be happy if I could see for myself that we're heading in the right direction. I've not felt that so far under ETH and actually think we've gone backwards this season. I can see what he's trying to do, but I just don't like it. I don't think it's title winning football in the PL.

I also think some of his in game decisions are bewildering at times, and he seems incredibly slow to come to conclusions that fans reached weeks before him. His eye for a player is poor, and that raises more questions for me with regards to how good he is at assessing opposition players and finding the best roles for his players.
 

AndyMUFC86

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Oct 18, 2021
Messages
194
Those defending Ten Hag all season have insisted all a manager needs to succeed, is a good structure and time (because they'll definitely become Fergie or Arteta)

Therefore why would you be so against Southgate? He'll have the structure, all we need to do is give him time. What's the problem?
Did you really just put Fergie and Arteta in the same bracket!
 

Rista

Full Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2006
Messages
2,578
Reluctant to sack without a clear plan to appoint a replacement... So why does it take so long for us to have a plan? It's not like we had to wait until the season is over to start making plans.
 

Chairman Steve

Full Member
Joined
May 9, 2018
Messages
7,347
It does seem increasingly likely that INEOS will keep ETH and then sack him in mid-season for Southgate, once Southgate has take all the time off he needs after the Euros are done with.
That would be up there for the most downright weirdest way to go about appointing a new manager in the history of association football.
 

lex talionis

Full Member
Joined
Jul 25, 2017
Messages
14,762
That would be up there for the most downright weirdest way to go about appointing a new manager in the history of association football.
If Southgate were the next Ancelotti I'd be ok with this, as shitty as it would be for ETH himself. But Gareth is no Carlo, not even close.