Formations and tactics obviously matter, but what matters even more is the execution of basic skills. It sounds hyperbolic to claim this, but I see a lot of poor execution of basic skills from United players over the last 12 months. Both under Ole and still under Ralf. Apart from De Gea no one has performed consistently well, in terms of individual execution of basic skills, all season.
Address that and we’ll create scoring chances. And maybe finish on some of them.
it’s a result of players not understanding, or maybe poor execution of the tactics. I’m not going to talk about Ole days as this is behind us now. Under Ralf, I see that players are lost. some key observations I’ve had so far:
- where is the gegenpressing we kept hearing about when ralf’s name was put forward? I dont know much about ralf, but from what i read, i expected a better pressing game. Only saw this in his first game in charge.
- excessive change in positions during the game. At one point against Newcastle, rashford was deep in central midfield creating play. What was that!
- bruno is out of position. If we want him back to his best, and he is actually a pretty good player, he needs to play in his preferred position. Not on the left or deep as a CM.
- full backs look bad because of the role they are given. They are basically asked to cover the whole wing area (defensively and offensively) as wingbacks although they are not part of a formation that requires and covers wingbacks, such as 343.
- full backs are often the highest players forward which leaves them with limited options. Basically, pass the ball backwards as they don’t have a winger there. Dalot, to his credit, managed a good assist to cavani. But that is and will continue to be a rare scene.
- central midfield still lacks creativity. I would have thought one of the things ralf would do is give vdb more game time as he is the only cm who knows how to pass the ball forward.
he is an interim manager and i don’t think he’ll be given the full time job. So is he preparing the team for next year as he should be? No. The two favorites, pochettino and ten hag, do not play 4222. So why invest in this?
also, a good manager works with the tools he has to get the best out of his players. This is not done. We have a team packed with wingers and we play with none… im not saying ralf is a bad manager, i actually dont know, but just an observation.
as a theory, i absolutely hate this formation. In practice, i have not seen anything to make me rethink this. Ralf is lucky to take charge during a relatively easy series of games. Imagine playing like this in the fixtures during Ole’s last 45 days…
more questions than answers at this stage for me.