Point well taken. Also, we have two attacking players, Rashford and Martial, who fancy themselves dribblers who consistently dribble into two defenders and lose possession of the ball. Rashford has the explosiveness but not the talent to beat defenders in tight spaces; Martial has the talent the beat defenders but he’s lost the explosiveness he had 3 seasons ago. Greenwood has both but is still in development. Those three are too selfish and just don’t look for the quick pass and the invention that can pick apart lesser clubs.
Yeah I think a lot of the time your players aren't placed in the optimal positions to succeed. It's been said elsewhere, but I agree with the (seeming) consensus that United are over-reliant on individualism for success rather than through a cohesive system.
Personally I think some sort of 3-4-1-2 would be interesting:
----------Rashford----Cavani-------------
---------------------Bruno----------------------
Shaw---Fred-----McT----Greenwood
-------Telles------Maguire---AWB------
-----------------Henderson------------------
Probably couldn't use this against the Burnleys of the world, but this way you have Telles as a weapon to cross from deep areas, Shaw on the overlap, Greenwood to mostly stay high and wide to provide an outlet with AWB in behind, a proactive goalkeeper to help make up for the slight downgrade aerially (though I think Maguire, Shaw, Cavani, McTominay, and Greenwood are probably sufficient to cope with most sides). Plus when out of possession, Shaw can step back into the centre with Telles going wider. Obviously this is somewhat inspired by Tuchel's use of CHO at wing back against low block teams - his usage in that position has really been a revelation in terms of our ability to stretch opponents horizontally.
Agree I've said for a while that our use of the wide areas is very poor and we don't utilise the overlap effectively very often.
Frankly it shouldn't matter what our wide players want to do, they need to follow instructions. If staying wide and creating 2v1 via overlaps is what is going to get us more wins, that's what they need to do. It all comes back to coaching again.
Agreed. I really wonder whether creating these sorts of situations is prioritised at all in training - right before Bruno's goal vs. Everton I believe you had an actual 3v2 opportunity on the wing, but no one actually tried to take advantage of the situation by making a diagonal run towards the penalty area. Obviously it worked out thanks to Bruno's brilliance, but that doesn't seem a sustainable way to create an attacking framework if you ask me.