Moyes So Far!

Status
Not open for further replies.
I wonder what the reaction in the media and on here will be if we fail to beat Stoke at the weekend. It's acceptable that we are going through a bad patch and are a team in transition, but we should be beating Stoke at home. Anybody should.
 
Does anyone else feel reassured by the things that Moyes is increasingly getting right? That is to say, he appears to be learning. Most obviously he's started playing the right players out wide and in defence. If he was still sticking with Rio and Young I'd be deeply concerned, but as it is he's showing that he's coming to terms with the squad.
 
Great article and pretty much sums up everything Moyes has been doing wrong. He just doesn't have a clear idea of what to do. He will be given to the end of the season to show what he can do but the constant list of excuses is tiring.

Klopp will not come but I don't mind Solksjaer to come back - I would have gone for Solskjaer over Moyes everytime.

None of us know how long he will be given since we aren't the ones making the decisions.
 
So one's not allowed to think the players are probably good enough and the manager's probably good enough but it's not that unpredictable that they're struggling a bit for flow and stability 11 games into their symbiosis given how deeply rooted the last guy's way of doing things was..?


Yes, that's exactly what a lot of people think but it doesnt sound as catchy does it? Some posters have a little bit more in common with sports journos than they would probably care to admit, paring everything down to simplified generalities that look quite clever on first read but upon closer inspection reveal very little about reality.
 
I expect... I expect... I expect ... I also expect ... I expect

Expect what you want.... The reality is, that after 26 years, no one was going to walk into Utd and have a seamless transition, unless the team is full of world class players in their mid 20's. Add to that that Moyes himself has had the same job for 10 years, so even if we did have a squad full of world beaters, there would be an adjustment period for the manager.
 
If top 4 is looking doubtful come February I could see the yanks panicing and sacking him I really could. No champions league football doesn't feature in their business plan I'm sure.
 
Let me know when you have anything of value to contribute with. I won't be holding my breath.

Saliph, for someone as arrogant as you, it's quite funny to see a post like this being made by you.:

Compared to Real, Barca, Bayern, and even City, there is a distinct lack of top class players in our squad, and compared to many other clubs (Arsenal, Dortmund, Atletico Madrid, PSG) our players don't seem to gel nearly as well as theirs. We have no more than 3 or 4 players that would stand a chance of getting into all those teams' starting 11s: De Gea, Rafael, RvP and Rooney (on his best, but in my opinion he's way too inconsistent, and way too often well below par, even if he's been relatively good so far this season, at least compared to the rest of the team. To be fair he has a shower of shite behind him in CM, but still I think he'd struggle to get into the team of many of the aforementioned clubs).

Too many aging stars and key players (Vidic, Rio, Evra, Carrick, Giggs) that aren't even close to the level they were in '08, and yet 4 of them have (up until now anyway) still been considered part of our best eleven. And none of their would-be replacements are in the same class as they were. Add to that that we've lost players like Scholes and Ronaldo in the meantime and the picture gets grimmer.

So far this season, my impression is that SAF left Moyes an aging, weary squad riddled with mediocrity that only he could've squeezed one last title out of IMO, reminiscent of '04-06. We haven't played really great football in years, and our defense and midfield aren't even close to being able to compete with the best in Europe at the moment - especially our midfield.

I think Moyes has a bigger challenge ahead of him than many thought before the season, and that a massive overhaul is needed (which is why it's doubly, triply, quadruply disappointing that we screwed up so badly during the summer). Get rid of Rio, Anderson, Giggs, Valencia, Evra (leaving anyway), Young, possibly Vidic (might be wise to keep him another year) and possibly Fellaini (depending on whether his performances improve or not, but I doubt it) at the end of the season. Buy 2 CMs (both of which should be top class), a RW, a LB and possibly a CB in January/next summer.

Oh, the irony. Some of the stuff you have said is quite ridiculous.
 
What makes Ole a better manager than Moyes? Completely unproven and hasn't exactly pulled up trees with Molde.

Yep two titles in a row with a club that hadn't won the title before is piss easy.
 
Still baffles me why we never went for someone like Guardiola (would have been available when ferguson decided to retire), Klopp or Joachim Low. Such a massive gamble with Moyes being thrust into an unfamiliar environment not only having to prove he can cut it to the footballing world but more importantly to the players that have essentially proved it all before time and time again. I get the early impression it was a big mistake that could have been handled better.
 
Still baffles me why we never went for someone like Guardiola (would have been available when ferguson decided to retire), Klopp or Joachim Low. .

Guardiola likes to inherit a team, Low is hardly going to quit the Germany job a year before the WC and Klopp seems pretty happy where he is.
 
Still baffles me why we never went for someone like Guardiola (would have been available when ferguson decided to retire), Klopp or Joachim Low. Such a massive gamble with Moyes being thrust into an unfamiliar environment not only having to prove he can cut it to the footballing world but more importantly to the players that have essentially proved it all before time and time again. I get the early impression it was a big mistake that could have been handled better.

I wonder how much Guardiola knew about Fergie retiring.
 
Guardiola likes to inherit a team, Low is hardly going to quit the Germany job a year before the WC and Klopp seems pretty happy where he is.

Guardiola took over a talented Barcelona team in disarray, he'd have no issue trying his luck at United and it'd have been a challenge he'd probably endorse but we were late to that party. Actually both him and Klopp are likely to leave Germany in 2016 so that could be our chance.
 
Guardiola likes to inherit a team, Low is hardly going to quit the Germany job a year before the WC and Klopp seems pretty happy where he is.


To be fair he has developed the Bayern team further, quite a feat when you consider they had won virtually everything last year.
 
I wonder what the reaction in the media and on here will be if we fail to beat Stoke at the weekend. It's acceptable that we are going through a bad patch and are a team in transition, but we should be beating Stoke at home. Anybody should.

I'm afraid, the Caf might need to shut down for a couple days. Otherwise it could lose half of its members due to banning.
 
Saliph, for someone as arrogant as you, it's quite funny to see a post like this being made by you.:



Oh, the irony. Some of the stuff you have said is quite ridiculous.

Still waiting. Still not holding my breath.
 
I believe that Guardiola was probably first choice, when he was unattainable we moved to Moyes, I think Joses antics meant he would never be given the chance and I think because Moyes had done his 10 year apprentiship the board thought it more fair to give it to a younger british manager than someone like Klopp.

Going with the best manager who could guarantee short/ medium term success would probably have been a better shout as we are never going to repeat what ferguson has done.
 
Was it ever confirmed that the two of them met in New York?

I don't know, mate. I remember they were rumours.


Still waiting. Still not holding my breath.

Poor Saliph. All it is with you is insults. When you can construct a better post in this thread that portrays you have an open mind, then I might consider replying to it, but with the ridiculous post you came up with, there really is no response for it, other than
 
Wow, me calling you out on your ridiculous religious beliefs really hurt your feelings didn't it.

Yes, what a brilliant post indeed.. :wenger:

What does religion have to do with this? I don't recall debating with you. I'm talking about this:

Too many aging stars and key players (Vidic, Rio, Evra, Carrick, Giggs) that aren't even close to the level they were in '08, and yet 4 of them have (up until now anyway) still been considered part of our best eleven. And none of their would-be replacements are in the same class as they were. Add to that that we've lost players like Scholes and Ronaldo in the meantime and the picture gets grimmer.

You blatantly forget that Vidic was amazing in 10/11 and the second half of 12/13. You also forget that Evra was very good last season. You also forget Ferdinand was excellent in 10/11, 11/12, and 12/13. And you also forget that Carrick was arguably the best midfielder in the league in 11/12 and 12/13.
 
What does religion have to do with this? I don't recall debating with you. I'm talking about this:



You blatantly forget that Vidic was amazing in 10/11 and the second half of 12/13. You also forget that Evra was very good last season. You also forget Ferdinand was excellent in 10/11, 11/12, and 12/13. And you also forget that Carrick was arguably the best midfielder in the league in 11/12 and 12/13.

Sure you don't.

No, I've not forgotten that. Bit too harsh on Carrick perhaps, but he's starting to age too.
 
Sure you don't.

No, I've not forgotten that.

That first line sums you and your arrogance up perfectly.

Yeah, they're not at the level they were in 2008, despite three of them having excellent seasons since 2008. What ridiculous logic.
 
I agree with the point on our big players not gelling and I think that's one of the reason we end up relying on individual brilliance so often to win matches.

When was the last time Rooney really produced a clear understanding with his strike partner, for example? Maybe Saha?
 
Ole and Gary Neville...I would be confident.

To be honest there was/is part of me that thinks that while we did the rigth thing in not going for a big name mercenary (JM), the appealing alternative was to go in for a United great. Ole certainly seems to be leading the line at the moment.

Either that or a Bruce - Keane - Robson - Strachan - Hughes - Ince team effort!
 
People actually think Ole would be a better candidate?

Molde are 5th in the Norweign league ffs, won 11 of 27 games.
 
That first line sums you and your arrogance up perfectly.

Yeah, they're not at the level they were in 2008, despite three of them having excellent seasons since 2008. What ridiculous logic.

Arrogance is underrated.

The logic is sound, I have no idea what you're talking about. Of course they can have good seasons (certainly wouldn't call them excellent, with the possible exception of Carrick) without being as good as they were. But in any case that's not the point I was making, which was that right now they're far off from where they were, and none of them have been adequately replaced (nor has Scholes for that matter). And they're not getting any younger.
 
To be honest there was/is part of me that thinks that while we did the rigth thing in not going for a big name mercenary (JM), the appealing alternative was to go in for a United great. Ole certainly seems to be leading the line at the moment.

Either that or a Bruce - Keane - Robson - Strachan - Hughes - Ince team effort!

sorry...none of those combinations give me confidence :nervous:
 
That first line sums you and your arrogance up perfectly.

Yeah, they're not at the level they were in 2008, despite three of them having excellent seasons since 2008. What ridiculous logic.


You think they're all at the level that they were in 08? Now that is ridiculous. Ferdinand was probably the best defender in the world that season.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.