Covid Outbreak at Man Utd

Status
Not open for further replies.
Pro choice mate vaccinated or unvaccinated you can still catch covid. Trust me yea don't want to go down vaccine mandatory route.
You do know reasons to get the vaccine is not just to lower transmission rate, right?
 
Infections are just one part of the problem.

Isn't it the case that isolation rules for non vaccinated are different so we could lose players who haven't even tested positive for 10 days because of their contacts (eg. their partner at home)?
Yup. That's the crux of the problem and I can fully understand why mandatory vaccination is being talked about. It's not about preventing spread, it's about not having to isolate for 10 days and miss 2/3/4 games.
 
I love how anti-vax is now called pro-choice.

I've yet to encounter an intelligent person who is 'pro-choice'... sadly even some of my (distant) relatives are of this persuasion. The common theme? They are not very bright. At all.
I fully agree. I’ll never understand the pro choice argument when it comes to safeguarding once health and protecting others. And it is completely normal for someone to have initial reservations over getting vaccinated - I speak to patients about this all the time- but the anti-vaccine stance seems rather reactionary, baseless and immature.
 
I'd be curious to see how many of the posters on here, labelling others as "anti-vaxxers", get their annual flu jab.

I'm guessing less than 50%.
 
I'd be curious to see how many of the posters on here, labelling others as "anti-vaxxers", get their annual flu jab.

I'm guessing less than 50%.
Not that it is in any way relevant to COVID but they don't offer it on the NHS to me otherwise I would get it if medical experts advised me to. I'll always listen to medical experts over random nutters on Facebook and Twitter.
 
Pro Vax (or just not an idiot) but also pro choice. A government shouldn't be mandating a vaccine. People are not the property of the state. However they should be opted out of state provided care (i.e. the NHS) should they decide to not get the vaccine. This applies to all vaccines. We'll see how people's opinions fare when they have to pay the real cost of treatment... Or die.
 
Pro Vax (or just not an idiot) but also pro choice. A government shouldn't be mandating a vaccine. People are not the property of the state. However they should be opted out of state provided care (i.e. the NHS) should they decide to not get the vaccine. This applies to all vaccines. We'll see how people's opinions fare when they have to pay the real cost of treatment... Or die.
Do you also suggest refusing to treat someone for lung or throat cancer because they smoke or previously did?
 
I'd be curious to see how many of the posters on here, labelling others as "anti-vaxxers", get their annual flu jab.

I'm guessing less than 50%.
Covid vaccine is available to everyone for free, flu vaccines are offered to vulnerable groups. It's not comparable.

My work would however arrange flu vaccines for everyone in the office and most people would take it.
Do you also suggest refusing to treat someone for lung or throat cancer because they smoke or previously did?
The NHS is not buckling under the weight of trying to treat people with smoking induced cancer so that is a bad comparison too.
 
So many misunderstand the vaccines. I always see dumb analogies on my social media with things like "If someone gave you scissors that didnt cut anything, would you advise others to buy them? NO!"

A more fitting analogy would be along the lines of having someone stand in front of you, smack them hard over the head with a steel bat. Their skull could be cracked, they have a brain bleed and die. Stick a helmet on the next person and hit them hard over the head with a steel bat. They have a sore head sure, but not a cracked skull and survive. They still suffer a bit because of the hit to head. Would they tell everyone not to wear a helmet cos they still got hit and it hurt?"
Humans are mysterious. We put things in our body every day that we don’t know what is truly in it or what long term effects it will have. Some choose to put things in their body knowing full well what long term effects it will have. However, for the most part, those choices won’t directly affect the person next to you. COVID is a virus. It’s spread is airborne. It might kill you or it might not. You could spread it to someone else who gets really sick and dies. Given the choice to prevent the spread and potentially killing someone else is the right thing to do. If you can’t or don’t want to do that then you should alter your social habits accordingly. The problem is most won’t do that and will just go on as usual. Then you have those who are nuts, stupid, or both and believe the vaccine has a chip in it. They probably also believe the earth is flat. Those same people will spew their rhetoric from a smart phone which does more tracking than an imbedded chip in your body would ever do. You can’t reason with these people.

I know several people who died from COVID. All unvaccinated. A few before the vaccine was available. Some of their family and friends still refuse to be vaccinated. I tell them to at least have their affairs in order so the shitstorm of them suddenly dying does not burden their family.
 
I love how anti-vax is now called pro-choice.

I've yet to encounter an intelligent person who is 'pro-choice'... sadly even some of my (distant) relatives are of this persuasion. The common theme? They are not very bright. At all.
Hit the nail on the head.
 
I'd be curious to see how many of the posters on here, labelling others as "anti-vaxxers", get their annual flu jab.

I'm guessing less than 50%.

Life must be a struggle for you with this sort of thinking. Or lack there of.
 
How has this turned into a vaccine/anti vaccine thread? Can’t escape this shite even on a football forum :( :nervous:

nothing anywhere suggests that the players who have covid aren’t vaccinated, most of them probably are by now.
 
Unfortunately being vaccinated doesn't preclude you from catching it and spreading it. People have a profound misunderstanding of vaccines. (not saying you do btw) They contain a small inactive part of the virus which triggers your bodies own immune system response to create B cell and T cell immune responses. This is no different from if you had been infected naturally and created the same response. The only difference is how hard you get hit by it, with a vaccine you personally suffer fewer symptoms than with a full blown infection.

Really at this point, with the majority of the country already having had covid getting a vaccine, or all 3 makes absolutely no difference between passing on the virus. The reason we're seeing more cases now, isn't because people aren't vaccinated against it it's because the latest variant has had to become more transmissible to survive. Because, even if players were vaccinated they would still catch it and pass it on and test positive (so we'd be in the same situation) the only difference would be their own personal symptoms. The rate of transmission doesn't change.

Again, I feel like how vaccines work is misunderstood. It's artificially jump starting your bodies own anit-bodies to create an immune response. No different from if you have caught the virus and created these anti-bodies yourself and it does not alter the rate of transmission or provide any protection against catching the virus. It's purely for your own protection.

Vaccines are not purely for your own protection. They are for you own protection as well as for the protection of the society you live in. A high vaccination rate may not stop the spreading, but it does slow it down and, more importantly, reduces the number of people requiring intensive care.

A mandate should be a last resort. However, if the healthcare in your country is on the brink of collapse, and you have tried all other measures, then it may be necessary with some mandates.
 
Confirmed United players who were at Carrington on Wednesday:

Cristiano Ronaldo, Fred, Victor Lindelof, Amad, Marcus Rashford, Eric Bailly, Raphael Varane, Diogo Dalot, Scott McTominay, Anthony Martial, Aaron Wan-Bissaka, Lee Grant, David de Gea, Bruno Fernandes, Edinson Cavani, Phil Jones, Alex Telles, Tahith Chong.

https://t.co/njDnlLJI64

Cobble together a starting 11 out of that;

De Gea

Dalot
Bailly
Varane
Telles

Mcfred

Fernandes
Rashford

Cavani
Ronaldo

not bad really. Just missing Sancho and Maguire from the team that beat Norwich. And Greenwood must be out and have to self-isolate because he's not vaccinated and came into contact with someone who has covid. Not because he has covid because he had covid recently and recovered.
 
I'd be curious to see how many of the posters on here, labelling others as "anti-vaxxers", watch the masked singer?

I'm guessing less than 97%. Am I doing this right?
 
I love how anti-vax is now called pro-choice.

I've yet to encounter an intelligent person who is 'pro-choice'... sadly even some of my (distant) relatives are of this persuasion. The common theme? They are not very bright. At all.

This is absolutely spot on.

I was engaging with somebody the other day after they tweeted that they were sick of being labelled as an anti-vaxxer and they were 'pro choice'. They said "being pro choice doesn't make me anti anything".

Me: "but you are against the vaccine, right. There anti-vaccine?"

Them: "Yeah, but that's not the point i'm making..."

:nervous:
 
Glad to hear Bailly and Martial are ok. Gonna need them for the xmas run in
 
The cancellation was due to the fact the training ground was shut all Monday so we had no time to prepare for the game.
Rather than the no. Of cases or something like that? Thanks, didn't realise that
 
Confirmed United players who were at Carrington on Wednesday:

Cristiano Ronaldo, Fred, Victor Lindelof, Amad, Marcus Rashford, Eric Bailly, Raphael Varane, Diogo Dalot, Scott McTominay, Anthony Martial, Aaron Wan-Bissaka, Lee Grant, David de Gea, Bruno Fernandes, Edinson Cavani, Phil Jones, Alex Telles, Tahith Chong.

https://t.co/njDnlLJI64

Cobble together a starting 11 out of that;

De Gea

Dalot
Bailly
Varane
Telles

Mcfred

Fernandes
Rashford

Cavani
Ronaldo

not bad really. Just missing Sancho and Maguire from the team that beat Norwich. And Greenwood must be out and have to self-isolate because he's not vaccinated and came into contact with someone who has covid. Not because he has covid because he had covid recently and recovered.
If the list is accurate, there's absolutely no reason to doubt whether the next match will go ahead.
 
I'd be curious to see how many of the posters on here, labelling others as "anti-vaxxers", get their annual flu jab.

I'm guessing less than 50%.
They aren't remotely related.

I only started getting the flu jab about 5 years ago because I took absolute stinker of a flu at Xmas 2 years in a row. Up until that I had hardly ever got the flu.

I'm not going to wait around and see how badly covid hits me before I decide to get the vaccine or not.
 
How has this turned into a vaccine/anti vaccine thread? Can’t escape this shite even on a football forum :( :nervous:

nothing anywhere suggests that the players who have covid aren’t vaccinated, most of them probably are by now.
Wasn't there a report/article somewhere that said most footballers weren't vaccinated?
 
I'd be curious to see how many of the posters on here, labelling others as "anti-vaxxers", get their annual flu jab.

I'm guessing less than 50%.

Covid vaccines are available and offered to everyone, annual flu jabs are not.

You'll probably be banned soon so don't know why I've bothered replying but stupidity needs to be called out.
 
If the list is accurate, there's absolutely no reason to doubt whether the next match will go ahead.

Maguire, Shaw, Matic, VDB, Lingard, Mata, Sancho, Greenwood, Elanga, Henderson and Heaton affected by COVID outbreak. 11 players in total.

Some will be positive cases (probably around 3-4) and the rest will be because they are unvaccinated like Mason Greenwood we know now is definitely not vaccinated because he wouldn't get Covid as he only just had it a few weeks ago. So he must have to self-isolate because he's unvaccinated and obviously came into contact with the Covid positive player (s). If you are vaccinated you don't need to self-isolate as a contact.

the Premier League only care about positive cases (3-4). They will say it's tough shite if you have unvaccinated players that's your problem not ours. So the game against Brighton is on unless both teams report a raft of new cases before Saturday and both want and agree to postpone the game.
 
Last edited:
Personally I'm pro vaccination and encourage everyone around me to be vaccinated. I was for government mandated vaccinations early on, but am now 'pro-choice' with respect to government mandates. However I think the individual clubs would be well within their (moral...not sure about legal) rights to require their own players to be vaccinated, just as they require them to not drink, not stay out late, not play other competitive sports during the season for fear of injury, etc... The players accept all sorts of restrictions and obligations in order to maintain a high physical level as part of their commitment to the club, and I don't see anything wrong with the club forcing vaccines on the players for the same sorts of reasons.
 
I love how anti-vax is now called pro-choice.

I've yet to encounter an intelligent person who is 'pro-choice'... sadly even some of my (distant) relatives are of this persuasion. The common theme? They are not very bright. At all.
A remarkable generalisation that.

I've had my vaccine, before you decide to have a pop. My wife worked in ITU for 6 years in one of the largest hospitals in the country, she's left now, but her best friend is still there who has now moved into a bed manager position. She's refusing to get the vaccine because of the huge increase in patients being admitted with strokes, the overwhelming majority of which have received the vaccine. This is someone that's been in the thick of it for 2 years, has seen both sides, but she's come to her own decision.

Let's not act like everyone that doesn't happily lap up every vaccine sent our way is some sort of thick shit that should be taken out of the gene pool.
 
If players want to the dough, get the vaccine or forego salary for missed games. A lot of other more worthwhile professions get paid a lot less but require you to get jabs, so it's a personal choice.

They can always go and be a shopkeeper or something and never be asked for vaccine status.

As for those who may not be vaccinated, it'll quickly become clear if we have outbreaks in our or opposing teams, as players would be out for weeks without training, let alone playing games.
 
Confirmed United players who were at Carrington on Wednesday:

Cristiano Ronaldo, Fred, Victor Lindelof, Amad, Marcus Rashford, Eric Bailly, Raphael Varane, Diogo Dalot, Scott McTominay, Anthony Martial, Aaron Wan-Bissaka, Lee Grant, David de Gea, Bruno Fernandes, Edinson Cavani, Phil Jones, Alex Telles, Tahith Chong.
When did he come back into the fold?
 
Fekkin hell even the wooden top reds who stuck by Ole aren't so thick as to be anti-vax.
 
A remarkable generalisation that.

I've had my vaccine, before you decide to have a pop. But my wife worked in ITU for 6 years in one of the largest hospitals in the country, she's left now, but her best friend is still there who has now moved into a bed manager position. She's refusing to get the vaccine because of the huge increase in patients being admitted with strokes, the overwhelming majority of which have received the vaccine. This is someone that's been in the thick of it for 2 years, has seen both sides, but she's come to her own decision.

Let's not act like everyone that doesn't happily lap up every vaccine sent our way is some sort of thick shit that should be taken out of the gene pool.
Is your wife's friend a scientist or just a random nurse? Because you talk about generalisations (and use the word wrongly) and then go on about some random person who may or not have a clue.

The last two years have shown that nurses and even doctors are not immune to stupidity. And even if there is a risk of the vaccine, as a whole, it benefits society.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.